The VFL will name a squad of 35 this week for the WAFL state game.

Who from your club is or should be a walk up starter and who are your smokies to be named going on form after only 4 rounds of VFL footy ?

3 walk ups for the Roosters if fit - Orren Stephenson,Steven Clifton and Myles Sewell.

Be interesting to see if anyones smokies get selected.

paul Mon, 3 May 2010 - 22:07

Baguley, Proctor, Hibberd and Gabriel potential squad members from Frankston - young 6'5 full back Marc Westcott as a smokey.

porky pies Mon, 3 May 2010 - 22:21

all those ballarat boys will be in the team you would think.. hibberd from frankston is a star who finds the footy and should make the squad.. also gabriel is a big man with great hands and will give selectors something to think about.. pinwill, brewer and dwyer from port too!

billythekid Tue, 4 May 2010 - 08:17

Why dont the VFL(sic) just take Nt Ballarat as they are clearly the best team in the comp.
These fake "state" games are a total non event for the Victorian football public.Most likely none of the players selected would get a game at AFL level.
You only have to see the pathetic crowds to see that.Do you think anyone believes the current VFL team is the real Big V? A massive waste of time and money the VFL dosent have.

paul Tue, 4 May 2010 - 09:37

"Most likely none of the players selected would get a game at AFL level."

I think recent performances at AFL level by ex-VFL players shows this statement to be a fair way off the mark.

digs Tue, 4 May 2010 - 10:30

paul wrote:"Most likely none of the players selected would get a game at AFL level."

I think recent performances at AFL level by ex-VFL players shows this statement to be a fair way off the mark.

I agree Paul, I think every VFL club would have 2 0r 3 players that are capable of playing AFL footy if given the opportunity.
To think that Hawthorn had the opportunity to rookie Stephenson at the start of the year but decided he didn't fit the mould was a big error that they would dearly regret now.
Don't tell me that Little, Pinwell (Not pretty but effective) Sewell, Clifton etc would not get a kick at the next level.

billythekid Tue, 4 May 2010 - 10:58

paul wrote:"Most likely none of the players selected would get a game at AFL level."

I think recent performances at AFL level by ex-VFL players shows this statement to be a fair way off the mark.

So a couple out of how many?

The thing is the VFL for all intents and purposes is now the AFL reserves (if you dont believe me go to Bigfooty and see how the AFL fans see it) and yes there are are a few players running around that might make in in the big league but my point is, this is NOT the Victorian State team in any shape or form and should called what it is a VFL team not even using the best (AFL) players in the comp so how can it give any indication as to the real standard of play in the VFL?.
The whole concept is a farce and should be scrapped.

billythekid Tue, 4 May 2010 - 11:04

digs wrote:

paul wrote:"Most likely none of the players selected would get a game at AFL level."

I think recent performances at AFL level by ex-VFL players shows this statement to be a fair way off the mark.

I agree Paul, I think every VFL club would have 2 0r 3 players that are capable of playing AFL footy if given the opportunity.
To think that Hawthorn had the opportunity to rookie Stephenson at the start of the year but decided he didn't fit the mould was a big error that they would dearly regret now.
Don't tell me that Little, Pinwell (Not pretty but effective) Sewell, Clifton etc would not get a kick at the next level.

Yes they might get a few kicks but wouldnt be able to handle the pressure over the season IE Skipworth Nahas. How many have gone on to be longterm stars at AFL level? Wether we like it or not there is the AFL then daylight

paul Tue, 4 May 2010 - 12:14

AFL then daylight is clearly not true given how the likes of Podsiadly, Barlow, Picken, Edwards, Boyd, Davey, Silvagni etc are going. Nahas had an excellent season last year - the new coach doesnt seem to like hmi but that doesnt devalue how well he performed at the top level.

Every week, VFL listed players perform as well as guys who get promoted into the AFL the next week.

No this isnt the Vic state team, but I dont think anyone is pretending it is. The VFA has played rep games for years without pretending to be 'the state team', and I see no reason why the VFL cant continue to do so. If you dont like it, dont watch.