Hi guys just wandering if i can get your opinions.
I have started following Bendigo Bombers. I have purchased a membership and I am getting more passionate about the club and league as I learn more everyday. I take my 3 boys to all the home games.
I am worried though that as we get attached more and more, what happens if Essendon pulls out of the alignment. I know the Diggers werent very popular and would have folded if it was not for the Bombers.
I dont want to follow a team for 2 or 3 years and then be left with nothing.
I think Essendon will persue the alignment and are reasonably happy with how it is working.
When Bendigo played as the Diggers, they struggled to get community support, and a lack of success only made things harder.
Personally, I liked the Diggers concept... Im a Port Melbourne supporter that would like to see the more clubs stand alone (The Borough included). However, to create a new club and get local support is difficult, and I think the Tasmania Devils would be the exception.
When they were forced to look at an alignment, I honestly thought Carlton may have made an arrangement with Bendigo (the area previously being a Carlton recruiting zone.
The Bombers have a chance to really build up the alignment, and practice matches (as was played this year) are a good way to bring potential supporters along to Bendigo games.
I was dissapointed to see that the Bendigo station that was calling the games their in previous seasons are not doing so this year. Someone correct me if I am wrong, but I think they had a special comments man who was blind?
Caveman, can you tell me, is the current alignment a 1,2 or 3 year deal?
I don't think the Bendigo concept is worthwhile.
Why? Because the side I've watched over the last two weeks is made up of 18 Essendon players and 4 "Bendigo" players (of which I think Doering, Hawkins, Moorcroft all live in Melbourne). It's like a travelling circus taking all these Melbourne based players up to the country.
I can't see any value in doing that (except for marketing) and it surely can't be of benefit to the players. They could do the same if they were called Essendon and they played at Windy Hill.
They need a reserves team, and more "Bendigo" product representing the club. A kid called Kain Robins who is on the Bendigo list had something like 45 possessions and 15 marks in a local Bendigo FL game a couple of weeks ago but can't crack it for a spot in the Bendigo Bombers side. And I think that is disappointing.
Essendon I think have two years left after this, the crowds seem alright, but if the Bendigo team don't make finals surely that would reduce the chances of it continuing. But to me I want to see Bendigo based players getting more of a go.
The problem I see with Bendigo is that Essendon isn't and never will be a good aligning partner.
I'm think that Essendon sees the alignment as a way of further promoting its interests rather than that of the Bendigo club and the VFL. I'm not even sure if the coach Peter Banfield takes training all that often during the season. On selection Essendon would select its players and then any spots left over would go to Bendigo players. And in a case like Saturday when Essendon don't have many injuries, then the side is basically Essendon players travelling to Bendigo to play football in a bastardised Essendon jumper.
The difference between Nth Ballarat and Bendigo is the Nth Ballarat started from a base and a powerful one at that. Bendigo is totally manufactured and I don't think that will work in the long term apart from a state side like Tasmania.
I am pretty sure there is 2 years after this one onslaught. Thanks for the replies guys and although it doesnt leave me very optomistic I think we will eventually get the VFL we want which is a cap on AFL listed players in the team.
One of the bombers best players this season is Guy Campbell and he does not live in Melbourne or is he listed to Essendon. He is a bendigo boy. I think we are along way off the perfect product in Bendigo but with a positive attitude and way of thinking we can achieve a team that represents Bendigo and satisfies Bendigo. Obviously the first move is to have a reserves team in the VFL. They are writing up plans and as long as the Bendigo Football League is happy we will have a reserves team next season. If that is achieved then we are a step closer to reaching our goal which is a team that Bendigo can identify with that has local talent mixed with Essendon players.