It may have just been me, but I didn't feel like Sunday's game was a Grand Final.
It could be for any number of reasons..
- Ports ressies were soundly defeated.
- Strong blustery winds often hurt the atmoshpere at the game
- Geelong had another week to go
- Coburg running through a banner with a Richmond jumpered tiger
- Not many fanatical VFA supporters. (The Come on Coburg was good to see two weeks running).
I might just be burnt out from a long season..
I'd be interested in hearing your thoughts on the day.
Seemed flat to me, but might just be sour grapes that Geelong won. For me only a Coburg victory could have saved the game but that never seemed likely.
Nothing against Geelong, but stand-alone AFL sides can demean the day if their club and supporters treat it as a Reserves match. 2002 was ok as Geelong had several young players who were on the up and Geelong seemed genuinely happy to win a flag. Last year many of the Geelong VFL players were scapegoated for Geelong underachieving at AFL level. And this year it was more of a dress reherasal for the big game next week.
Mark Thompson was quoted as saying that players may be rested throughout the match, with a view to next week. [I say quoted because I suspect the journalist was hunting for a story] This doesn't help the game.
The Geelong players though treated the game very seriously and never looked like losing. The 12/10 rule needs to be a level playing field. Rookies train with AFL clubs and thus across the board should be counted as AFL players.
With Geelong, Collingwood and possibly the Bulldogs fielding stand-alone VFL sides in 2008 the prospect of these sides meeting off in a grand-final is a real possibility.
The positives I thought were the size of the crowd - 10,000'ish?, and I thought having the Geelong cheer squad up behind the goals with their flags and floggers added to the occasion.
The biggest negative was the quality of the game. Listened to Rex Hunt on SEN driving home and he was pretty scathing about it - claimed it was of a poorer standard than the worst AFL game he'd seen this year.
"With Geelong, Collingwood and possibly the Bulldogs fielding stand-alone VFL sides in 2008 the prospect of these sides meeting off in a grand-final is a real possibility."[/quote]
If that happens the comp will be the VFL but in reality will be seen as only the AFL reserves.
The crowd was great but due mainly to the Geelong fans turning up in numbers as there didnt seem to be many Coburg/Richmond fans at all.The game panned out as I expected as Geelong were just too big ,too strong and too talented.
If this trend of AFL clubs fielding reserves sides continues one wonders if a stand alone club will make the finals let alone win a flag in the future.
Rex Hunt was right the game was very ordinary as a spectacle ( the blustery wind didnt help) with the Coburg skill level being very poor esp their so called better standard AFL players.
The crowd was excellent - 13,842.
I've heard a couple of people blame the poor skills on display in both the Ressies and Seniors on the wind, but for most of the day it was a minor breeze at best. Worse winds are found every week at Port Melbourne, Williamstown and Sandringham. It wasn't really an adequate excuse for Coburg's poor execution of even the most basic skills (particularly noticeable with their atrocious kick-ins and kicks inside forward 50).
Certainly was flat! Nearly 14,000, great crowd, but where i was, it was full of Richmond and Geelong "what about '67"..."At least we're in the Granny this year, where are you?" banter! And the Richmond jumper on the Coburg banner was a shocker! The game reminded me of the North Melb v Port Adelaide prelim the day before, with Coburg just never able to get any run going. And what were all those 10m grubber kicks they kept kicking? I know it was windy, but that was ridiculous.
The dimensions of Princes Park favour the AFL team, and the footy's not as dynamic as at the smaller VFL grounds, the players aren't used to the space. I've found that in most Granny's at the ground since it's been lengthend. Can Port Melbourne be bolstered to take 15,000? It's worth it I reckon.
If the game was tight, the atmosphere would've been fine! The crowd loved the 2nd quarter fight in the 2nd term, it was pretty close to us. And when that guy missed the 2nd shot at goal . . . that was my highlight of the day.
At least Tudor showed genuine emotion at winning the match, and Tom Lonergan certainly was a great footy story. James Byrne can add VFL premiership captain to his impressive CV, and what can't the Cats win?
I'm rambling! Bring on next year!
They cant go back to Port Melbourne.
The ground is bad enough when 3,000 are there for Prelim Finals let alone 14,000 for a Grand Final.
Try Telstra Dome if they want, but I'm pretty happy with Princes Park it has a suburban feel to it IMO.
Interesting to note that only 2 years ago Coburg finished 2nd last and Geelong last. Quite an impressive turnaround.
Can we look forward to Port v Bendigo in 08?