So who represents the VFL in the foxtel cup next year?

Slammin Sammy Says Mon, 15 Sep 2014 - 09:40

Box Hill would be one team.

The other team would be one of the losing preliminary finalists,Port Melbourne or Williamstown - whichever is considered to have finished 3rd. I'd say Port Melbourne given they finished on top of the ladder.

NorthPort Mon, 15 Sep 2014 - 10:05

Hope Port do qualify. It's one of the few chances as a supporter we get to travel interstate after the loss of Murray Kangaroos and the Tasmania Devils.

Mustang Mon, 15 Sep 2014 - 10:14

Actually, that's an interesting question.

I was under the impression that the defending champion was an automatic qualifier?

NorthPort Mon, 15 Sep 2014 - 10:55

Makes sense Mustang. And I'm guessing that means Port misses out. The Foxtel Cup has been rejigged a couple of times. I can't see three VFL sides being included.

Heath_eld Topic starter Mon, 15 Sep 2014 - 12:20

I thought "real" afl clubs (like footscray) weren't eligible - meaning box hill and either port or Williamstown would represent the VFL?

Slammin Sammy Says Mon, 15 Sep 2014 - 12:30

Correct Heath, AFL Reserves teams don't compete in the Foxtel Cup (Geelong last year for example)

I don't think there is a rule about the reigning champions competing the following year, but there have been several format changes so I could be wrong. I would be expecting Port Melbourne to be playing along with Box Hill.

NorthPort Mon, 15 Sep 2014 - 21:09

I wasn't aware of the reigning premier automatically qualifying either, and thought the top 2 VFL sides (excluding AFL standalone clubs) were selected.

Didn't Port and Werribee qualify the year after Williamstown won in the inaugural season?

jb Tue, 16 Sep 2014 - 07:22

In reply to by NorthPort

NorthPort wrote:

I wasn't aware of the reigning premier automatically qualifying either, and thought the top 2 VFL sides (excluding AFL standalone clubs) were selected.

Didn't Port and Werribee qualify the year after Williamstown won in the inaugural season?

Williamstown also played the 2nd year, but as they played in the VFL grand final would have qualified anyway - back then 3 VFL teams were involved, and Werribee would have qualified having made the Prelim.

riccardo Tue, 16 Sep 2014 - 13:04

According to the official site, the two highest finishing non-AFL reserves from the VFL WAFL and SANFL compete plus the premiers of the NEAFL and TSL.

So Box Hill (playing VFL listed players only) as Grand Finalist would get in. Port finished as as minor premier but Williamstown lost their prelim by a smaller margin, so it depends on who they consider to have finished third. The Seagulls are reigning premiers, but I don't think they get an invite just based on that.

jb Tue, 16 Sep 2014 - 13:35

In reply to by riccardo

riccardo wrote:

According to the official site, the two highest finishing non-AFL reserves from the VFL WAFL and SANFL compete plus the premiers of the NEAFL and TSL.

So Box Hill (playing VFL listed players only) as Grand Finalist would get in. Port finished as as minor premier but Williamstown lost their prelim by a smaller margin, so it depends on who they consider to have finished third. The Seagulls are reigning premiers, but I don't think they get an invite just based on that.

Presume Port would be considered finishing 3rd based on higher ladder position at the end of the season.