Given recent discussion on this forum, time to once again keep the press on their toes.

The Age takes the prize today for the best coverage of the VFL - 10 players are referred to in their VFL story, and five of them are VFL listed. In the Herald Sun, 12 players names are mentioned, yet only three of them VFL players.

I have two major issues with the VFL coverage in the daily papers. The first is journalists writing about games they aren't actually at. Stick to covering one game properly than trying to cover two games poorly. The best player on the ground at Werribee yesterday didn't get a mention, and it was far from Majak Daw's best VFL game. He's had a lot better games. I'm sorry to offend Sam Landsberger but I'm 99% certain he wasn't at Werribee yesterday.

My second hate is the lack of equality. At Werribee yesterday, Ben McKinley and Robbie Castello both kicked five goals. The Herald Sun conveniently left out the fact Castello booted five. And to say "North's Ben McKinley kicked five goals" - well, I'm sorry but Ben McKinley was a Werribee player yesterday. St Kilda's McQualter and Tom Ledger got a mention, so too did North Melbourne's Hamish McIntosh and Richmond's Ben Griffiths. Why do these articles constantly refer to the AFL club? Yesterday, these guys represented Werribee, Sandringham and Coburg - shouldn't they be referred to as such?

BrekkyDJ Mon, 27 Jun 2011 - 19:28

footyman wrote:Given recent discussion on this forum, time to once again keep the press on their toes.

The Age takes the prize today for the best coverage of the VFL - 10 players are referred to in their VFL story, and five of them are VFL listed. In the Herald Sun, 12 players names are mentioned, yet only three of them VFL players.

I have two major issues with the VFL coverage in the daily papers. The first is journalists writing about games they aren't actually at. Stick to covering one game properly than trying to cover two games poorly. The best player on the ground at Werribee yesterday didn't get a mention, and it was far from Majak Daw's best VFL game. He's had a lot better games. I'm sorry to offend Sam Landsberger but I'm 99% certain he wasn't at Werribee yesterday.

My second hate is the lack of equality. At Werribee yesterday, Ben McKinley and Robbie Castello both kicked five goals. The Herald Sun conveniently left out the fact Castello booted five. And to say "North's Ben McKinley kicked five goals" - well, I'm sorry but Ben McKinley was a Werribee player yesterday. St Kilda's McQualter and Tom Ledger got a mention, so too did North Melbourne's Hamish McIntosh and Richmond's Ben Griffiths. Why do these articles constantly refer to the AFL club? Yesterday, these guys represented Werribee, Sandringham and Coburg - shouldn't they be referred to as such?

Here Here!

You should have heard us Borough supporters getting stuck into Howard Leigh... who was just 2 metres away from us!!!

NorthPort Mon, 27 Jun 2011 - 21:38

I'm not sure there was much point getting stuck into Howard Leigh.. he's very approachable and I'm sure if you spoke to him you would find that he is under instruction to focus on particular players.

I think he finds it a little frustrating writing his articles with so much of an AFL slant.

billythekid Tue, 28 Jun 2011 - 07:57

The Sunday AGE coverage was a disgrace.All Diamond wrote about was the AFL players.

Slammin Sammy Says Tue, 28 Jun 2011 - 08:43

The Sunday Age seems to me to usually have 2 articles.

1 article is a feature on 1 game and will mention the better players whether they be VFL or AFL listed.

The other article is AFL player focused. It gives the other VFL games results and focuses on which AFL listed players are playing well (ie may be in line for an AFL recall) or are returning from injury.

paulamy Tue, 28 Jun 2011 - 11:01

Hi all. Brekky DJ now that you're on the Borough bandwagon I understand your frustration about the coverage. But I also understand Howard's position. He is asked to focus on AFL players. Let us not forget this man has been writing about the VFA/VFL for many years. Growing up, I got Inside Footy every week and Howard did a terrific spread, with crisp and colourful copy. I admire that he's still getting out there and doing the job, thrusting that big old tape recorder under the noses of coaches. He is a delightfully chatty fellow and a passionate VFL man. I'm disappointed you get on here bragging about ``getting stuck in'' to him. He deserves better.

footyman Topic starter Tue, 28 Jun 2011 - 11:34

paulamy wrote:But I also understand Howard's position. He is asked to focus on AFL players.

This is the problem. But are these editors right in believing that the majority of readers only want to hear about the AFL listed players?

In doing so, these articles really only paint half the picture of a game. To mention one player who kicked five goals, but exclude another who achieves the same result on the basis that one is on an AFL list and one isn't is a prime example of this.

Sorry, but it is offensive to VFL supporters, VFL clubs, and most importantly the VFL players when these papers focus so heavily on AFL listed players. The VFL players deserve just as much recognition. What further adds salt to the wound is that they waffle on about some ordinary AFL players who really didn't play that well.

I understand that people have to earn a crust, and they have to do what their editors tell them if they want a job in journalism. But if they are putting their name to these stories, then they are going to cop flack on this sort of VFL forum where the fans are passionate about VFL players and VFL clubs. If they are passionate about VFL then I'm sure these blokes would know the articles they are told to produce are far from ideal. I just hope they have a thick skin.