Careful.....don't criticise Frankston Park (Kars Street). It is such a fine ground that it attracted St Kilda FC to it. Unfortunately for St Kilda FC, there are so many problems (too many to list here) which have escalated the political and financial costs that now they're looking at Belvedere Park in the backblocks of Seaford. But that is even worse than Frankston Park, which looks like the MCG in comparison to Belvedere Park.
zebraman Sat, 26 Jul 2008 - 22:56
caseyscorp wrote:Careful.....don't criticise Frankston Park (Kars Street). It is such a fine ground that it attracted St Kilda FC to it. Unfortunately for St Kilda FC, there are so many problems (too many to list here) which have escalated the political and financial costs that now they're looking at Belvedere Park in the backblocks of Seaford. But that is even worse than Frankston Park, which looks like the MCG in comparison to Belvedere Park.
Belvedere Park...or further towards the CBD?? Just where will St Kilda end up??...cos it look like it won't be Kars St I await with interest....as I also await the news regarding the potential Melbourne/Casey affiliation
caseyscorp Topic starter Sat, 26 Jul 2008 - 23:02
It is a real problem for the Saints because they have the promise of a $1 million block of land which is in the commercial area of Frankston and which they'll lose if they don't go somewhere in Frankston. In reality they should go to Sandy or stay at Moorabbin. Moorabbin is the best option because there are no issues around building on adjacent Crown Land which would need to be resolved at Sandy. They already have the lease at Linton Street, so they don't need to negotiate tenancy rights. As well there is an additional $500,000 grant from the Govt to remove the existing stands. St Kilda needs to take the bit between its teeth, be prepared to dump the ever-increasingly costly Frankston venture and rebuild player facilities at Linton Street.
zebraman Sat, 26 Jul 2008 - 23:11
doubt if they'd end up at Sandy..the Bayside Council is hardly football friendly...the fence at Sandy proved that ....be a touch ironic if Moorabbin ended up being the destination...which is hardly a destination as they are already there Strange how some councils are football friendly.....others have virtually no idea that a team exists within their boundaries and they have this unusual conclusion that their AFL affiliate simply ploughs in mega bucks to the VFL team
footyman Sat, 26 Jul 2008 - 23:20
zebraman wrote:Strange how some councils are football friendly.....others have virtually no idea that a team exists within their boundaries and they have this unusual conclusion that their AFL affiliate simply ploughs in mega bucks to the VFL team
Thats one thing I admire with the City of Casey, they do have an appreciation for elite sport and building facilities to suit elite teams. Just not facilities good for spectators :lol: Nah, only joking caseyscorp. I'm with you both on this, the Saints should stick with Moorabbin. Its 20mins from town, most of their players are happy bayside residents, I actually think they've got the potential for a good set up down there with massive light towers and everything. And they've got a ground they can use all year round. So two questions remain: (1) how far away is an arrangement between Casey and Melbourne? Both ground usage and a VFL alignment? (2) What will happen with Frankston Park? Maybe the grandstand will get rebuild after all!!! Did they ever say their findings on that - deliberate? I hope it wasnt 'sacrificed' for the Saints redevelopment.
caseyscorp Topic starter Sat, 26 Jul 2008 - 23:22
It seems that most Councils are not football friendly - either to their AFL team if they have one or to their VFL team. I find it very strange, because the value of sporting clubs within any community is well known. Mind you the usual thing that I hear from local government people with an AFL club is how arrogant the AFL club is. But VFL clubs, being part of a local community should fare pretty well you'd think. Fortunately the Scorpions enjoy a very good relationship with Councillors (well most of them anyway) and Council officers at Casey Council. The Casey Council, having not had any elite sports clubs competing at a level such as the VFL, was keen to attract clubs at that level for a whole range of reason (aspirational, inspirational, spectating for the community). The Scorpions and the South Melbourne Cricket Club have both made Casey their home. As far as Melbourne FC goes, I think something might happen within the next month or so.
caseyscorp Topic starter Sat, 26 Jul 2008 - 23:32
footyman wrote:So two questions remain: (1) how far away is an arrangement between Casey and Melbourne? Both ground usage and a VFL alignment? (2) What will happen with Frankston Park? Maybe the grandstand will get rebuild after all!!! Did they ever say their findings on that - deliberate? I hope it wasnt 'sacrificed' for the Saints redevelopment.
(1) Local paper says Casey Council is considering it (MFC to Casey Fields)on 5 August. A decision on whether or not there will be an alignment is probably 2-4 weeks or so away. (2) According to paul, the grandstand is fully insured, so once St Kilda declares they are out of there, it should get fully rebuilt (hopefully without any further delay) - refer to earlier post quoted below: [quote:7d89e3374a="caseyscorp"][quote:7d89e3374a="paul"]Caseyscorp, if you knew nearly as much as you think you do about the insurance policy, you would know that the grandstand could not possibly have been underinsured. Most of your other points are quite valid, but you have been misled on that one.[/quote] Well I have to admit I don't know the insurance policy details - my comment was just based on a comment from someone who would. Anyway, if that's the case, it's great news for Frankston FC and Frankston Council - they get the grandstand rebuilt as was and at no cost.[/quote]
footyman Tue, 29 Jul 2008 - 13:43
http://cranbourne.yourguide.com.au/news/local/news/general/demons-may-w… Sounds very interesting. A win, win for all. Having an AFL club in their area, generating publicity, players mixing with the community...worth it I would've thought. Although it seems a few councellors are a little unhappy with the CEO. Reminds me of one of those door to door sales people who hurry you along and make you agree to something without letting you properly read all the fine print :lol:
caseyscorp Topic starter Tue, 29 Jul 2008 - 22:10
footyman wrote:Although it seems a few councellors are a little unhappy with the CEO. Reminds me of one of those door to door sales people who hurry you along and make you agree to something without letting you properly read all the fine print :lol:
The Councillor referred to in the article is publicly opposed to Melbourne coming to Casey and seems to dislike the CEO. I think you'd find that the majority of Councillors are supportive of both the Melbourne footy club and the CEO, and from what I know of them happy with the amount of information they've had about the proposal.
footyman Tue, 29 Jul 2008 - 22:17
caseyscorp wrote:The Councillor referred to in the article is publicly opposed to Melbourne coming to Casey and seems to dislike the CEO. I think you'd find that the majority of Councillors are supportive of both the Melbourne footy club and the CEO, and from what I know of them happy with the amount of information they've had about the proposal.
Good news!! I guess the ones who have the most to say are often the ones in the minority. The details in the article sounded very good. I think Casey should be applauded for what they are trying to do. Everytime I go down there the municipality is getting bigger and just something about the area that people dont mind a day out at a sporting event.
iceman Tue, 29 Jul 2008 - 22:20
footyman wrote:http://cranbourne.yourguide.com.au/news/local/news/general/demons-may-w… Sounds very interesting. A win, win for all. Having an AFL club in their area, generating publicity, players mixing with the community...worth it I would've thought. Although it seems a few councellors are a little unhappy with the CEO. Reminds me of one of those door to door sales people who hurry you along and make you agree to something without letting you properly read all the fine print :lol:
This sems a very good outcome for all involved, a good opportunity, lets see what happens on August 5th!