Forum topic

46 posts / 0 new
Last post
jasonborough
Congratulations to wazza carlyle great effort in whitch our team finished on the bottom
BigV
[quote]Sorry, posted up on wrong thread. I suspect the Davenport-Matthews situation could be explained by the fact that there were different selectors. They mentioned last night that Martin Stillman selected the team of the year [/quote] I think you find the selectors for the team of the year is the same as the selectors for the fothergill-round medal!
bcarbonaro
[quote="theobserver"]Sorry, posted up on wrong thread. I suspect the Davenport-Matthews situation could be explained by the fact that there were different selectors. They mentioned last night that Martin Stillman selected the team of the year[/quote] Just out of interest, who were the other selectors for the team of the year?
BigV
Announced at the Liston was Martin Stillman and Adrian Dunn
bcarbonaro
Talking Adrian Dunn, why doesn't he cover the VFL for the Herald Sun instead of Geoff Poulter? Why are the articles in the VFL Record not credited to a writer/s?
Dolphin
[quote="BigV"]How was Kyle Matthew's good enough to make the team of the year but not win the Fothergill-Round medal and on the flip side, Jason Davenport won the medal but didn't make the team of the year???????????[/quote] Totally agree. Would take Davenport before Mathews in a second. [quote:b933254c10="theobserver"]Sorry, posted up on wrong thread. I suspect the Davenport-Matthews situation could be explained by the fact that there were different selectors. They mentioned last night that Martin Stillman selected the team of the year[/quote] He selects both.
theobserver
I'd take Matthews ahead of Davenport. You can only go on what you see and I saw Matthews three times this year and he was fantastic every time. Davenport has been OK in both finals. But both are outstanding young players. If Reberschini had played a few more games I would have gone for him. I reckon he's got `it'.
theobserver
If what Big V says is right it doesn't make a lot of sense. But as Footman says it's a tough gig. Martin Stillman seemed to hit the Under 23 squads on the head. But I think most of the people who post up here could have dashed those squads off in 5mins.
Dolphin
The Under 23 squads are basically nominated by the clubs and the AFL recruiters.
bcarbonaro
Are you trying to be biased Dolphin?

Pages