It would make perfect sense for Port Melbourne to play a home Preliminary Final at Telstra Dome against say 'Sandy' to gain experience at the venue. It is more than likely that Port will struggle at TD if the Grand Final is their first run at Telstra. Especially if they play a Williamstown or Casey who's AFL club's have the Dome as their home ground, meaning several players of AFL experience would have a huge advantage over Port. In saying this Port have mnay AFL experienced players, the cost of the Dome wouldn't be cheap, availability is an issue(NRL) but it seems logical if Port really want the flag.
Heck you might be tricking me again. But I'll take this as serious.
A stupid idea!!!
I hear you ask why?
Firstly you cant guarantee Port will make a Prelim. Sides have been knocked out in straight sets before. So if that happened, would they cancel the booking or keep it?
Secondly, a Prelim Final draws about 5,000 people tops. It'd look shit on TV, take away from the community feeling of VFL footy and cost a lot of money.
Thirdly, vfa and his mates wouldnt like paying $5.40 or whatever it is for a cup of crappy beer.
Fourthy, I suspect there are arrangements in place with the ABC, Port Melbourne etc to play finals at TEAC Oval. Certainly the ABC infrastructure is set up at Port for the month of finals.
If Port need experience on the venue, try and get a training run there Grand Final week. Sides have played VFL Grand Finals at Princes Park in seasons where they did not play at the ground. This year is no different.
Port may be disadvantaged come a Grand Final if they make it, but they get a nice advantage during the lead up finals by playing at their home ground.
We all love the community feel of the VFL. The atmosphere of walking into Port Melbourne for finals on a sunny spring day, standing on the grass watching the footy, going onto the ground for a kick or to listen to the coaches. You just want somewhere that has a nice glass box for you to sit in and seem to lack an appreciation of the VFL, its history and what people want and love about the competition. I suspect this topic will be quickly shot down by others who also agree with my comments.
Just seeing if you'd follow my trail.
[quote:8d82bb0eb9="footyman"] I hear you ask why?[/quote] Yeah, all good points, and as you'll recognise - just creating discussion.
[quote:8d82bb0eb9="footyman"]We all love the community feel of the VFL. The atmosphere of walking into Port Melbourne for finals on a sunny spring day, standing on the grass watching the footy, going onto the ground for a kick or to listen to the coaches. [b]You just want somewhere that has a nice glass box for you to sit in and seem to lack an appreciation of the VFL, its history and what people want and love about the competition. [/b] I suspect this topic will be quickly shot down by others who also agree with my comments. [/quote]Now that's going personal again, it's simply an idea - that will further Port's chances of winning the flag. Not everyone has a hidden agenda footyman you need to understand this. However, your argument is comprehensive, that I can not doubt.
I think you are on the wrong track here VoiceoftheB...
First and foremost, TEAC OVal is a massive home ground advantage that the club would not want to give up, in what is the most importnat game in the season to that point. Lose and you are out. The Borough will do everything in their power to maximse their chances.
Secondly I believe Port Melbourne get part of the revenue from hosting the finals and would not want to give that up.
The Borough would probably only get a light run on the ground on the Wednesday or Thursday night prior to the GF (assuming that they get through to the GF).
Interesting idea, but I don't think it's something the VFL would look on too favourably either due to the costs involved.
Voice my friend, I can't believe you have written that crap. This competition is not all about Port. There are other clubs that think that they have a chance of winning this years flag. Port would have a great deal more players that have had the experience of playing at the Telstra Dome than say Frankston or North Ballarat.
Voice my friend, I can't believe you have written that crap. This competition is not all about Port. There are other clubs that think that they have a chance of winning this years flag. Port would have a great deal more players that have had the experience of playing at the Telstra Dome than say Frankston or North Ballarat.[/quote]Does anyone believe North Ballarat will struggle at the Dome? Possibly, however, Port will struggle the most because of their game plan and structure. North won't care just get it to Roach and it's all full-steam ahead from there. Willy, it won't bother them and if Casey don't get knocked out in straights I'll be surprised.
Back in ya boxes Port fans, Ya dish that crap up again you wont have to worry about a Prelim Final. All the talk is Willy& Port Grand Final to attract 20,000 plus - not bloody likely. Port done nothing to promote the VFL or the Grand Final today. Great 4 qtr effort today Dolphins.
aren't we getting a tad ahead of ourselves talking about preliminary finals in July???
At least wait until the home and away is over then start considering it...
Good one Sandy. Like I keep saying , worry about next week only.
Fantastic win by a stand alone club against a much more experienced & expensive side. A few dollars went down the drain yesterday. Brian Mace would not be able to get the smile off his face this morning.
Good one Sandy. Like I keep saying , worry about next week only.
Fantastic win by a stand alone club against a much more experienced & expensive side. A few dollars went down the drain yesterday. Brian Mace would not be able to get the smile off his face this morning.[/quote]Ease up digs,we had a bad day and frankston played very well.Port seem to struggle always down at frankston.
Port's record at Frankston is pretty poor. Even in the glory days they would struggle there. Full credit to Frankston who played a top game against the borough. Port can rebound against Werribee which will be a good test. Frankston can win again next week against Bendigo at home.