billythekid wrote:

footyman wrote:The thing is I can't actually see who is playing at Cramer St on Sunday????

According to the NFL website there is no game there.

At the end of the day its an AFL Victoria cock up because originally Bullants v Casey was on Saturday, then they moved it obviously without consulting the ground managers, then got themselves into a pickle.

There should be a Sunday game.

Just adds further credibility to my post last week which criticised AFL Victoria for their fixturing and planning of matches.

What credibility?The VFL is becoming more of a joke by the week! A well trained monkey could do a better job than the clowns at the VFL. As I have said on many occaisons that when the people that run an organization have no real feel or passion for the place then you are in deep poo poo and thats exactlly where the current VFL now finds itself.

Have got to admit Billy that things are not looking too bright for a viable competition in 2010.
The murmurs up here are that the Bendigo - Essendon relationship is over & also that The Dolphins may well be missing. I certainly hope that those rumours are incorrect.
Anybody else heard of any rumblings. ??

vfa Tue, 9 Jun 2009 - 21:00

Got a feeling that the following may happen ?
Could be a Coburg/Essendon combination next year with all games at Coburg with maybe one at Windy Hill. Richmond to go alone and be called the Craigeburn Tigers ?
Bendigo looks shaky ? Will the diggers reform ??
Frankston will tough it out as they have battled too hard to throw it away.
Injuries, new coach, lack of a grandstand due to last years fire and of course lack of funds are some problems. Hopefully the dolphins can came good. The comp desperately needs a Frankston as they add plenty to the comp. I can't really stomach Collingwood or Geelong or any want to be standalone AFL team.
Last year it was a good year for the standalone and partly aligned teams. This year it has North Ballarat entreched on top, Port still a chance but Frankston and Werribee have done poorly. To make things worse the Collingwood filth have won far too many games for my liking. Not good.

footyman Tue, 9 Jun 2009 - 21:30

In reply to by vfa

vfa wrote:Could be a Coburg/Essendon combination next year with all games at Coburg with maybe one at Windy Hill.

No.

Essendon more likely to go alone and play at Windy Hill.

vfa wrote:Richmond to go alone and be called the Craigeburn Tigers ?.

No. Richmond haven't got the funds to go it alone and a lot of the Coburg board are Richmond people. That alignment will stay I reckon.

vfa wrote:Bendigo looks shaky ? Will the diggers reform ??

Diggers no chance of returning.

vfa wrote:Frankston will tough it out as they have battled too hard to throw it away.

Agree. But probably with a new coach and a significant turnover of their playing list.

comeng Tue, 9 Jun 2009 - 21:37

In reply to by footyman

vfa wrote:Got a feeling that the following may happen ?
Could be a Coburg/Essendon combination next year with all games at Coburg with maybe one at Windy Hill. Richmond to go alone and be called the Craigeburn Tigers ?
Bendigo looks shaky ? Will the diggers reform ??
Frankston will tough it out as they have battled too hard to throw it away.
Injuries, new coach, lack of a grandstand due to last years fire and of course lack of funds are some problems. Hopefully the dolphins can came good. The comp desperately needs a Frankston as they add plenty to the comp. I can't really stomach Collingwood or Geelong or any want to be standalone AFL team.
Last year it was a good year for the standalone and partly aligned teams. This year it has North Ballarat entreched on top, Port still a chance but Frankston and Werribee have done poorly. To make things worse the Collingwood filth have won far too many games for my liking. Not good.

The Coburg Bombers? Craigieburn Tigers? Frankston Bombers? Frankston Tigers? Bendigo Diggers?

This competition needs strong standalone clubs to keep its credibility. When I read anything in the paper about the VFL it is only about the AFL players, hear reports on the radio the same thing. I don't read the paper or listen to the radio anymore. Even SEN's State of Play is the same stuff. The VFL is a good product with very poor marketing.

Perhaps it is time for the AFL to reform its own reserves comp. However, it that happens it would be curtains for most VFL clubs. Who would survive? Port, Williamstown, North Ballarat and Werribee perhaps? I don't know. Would people support an expanded SANFL comp including the VFL teams that can standalone and afford the travel? I would see the travel as being a killer for that idea.

I want to be positive about the comp, however it is hard when all you hear is that you follow the AFL reserves.

Enough rambling for now.

billythekid Wed, 10 Jun 2009 - 08:20

In reply to by comeng

This competition needs strong standalone clubs to keep its credibility. When I read anything in the paper about the VFL it is only about the AFL players, hear reports on the radio the same thing. I don't read the paper or listen to the radio anymore. Even SEN's State of Play is the same stuff. The VFL is a good product with very poor marketing.

Perhaps it is time for the AFL to reform its own reserves comp. However, it that happens it would be curtains for most VFL clubs. Who would survive? Port, Williamstown, North Ballarat and Werribee perhaps? I don't know. Would people support an expanded SANFL comp including the VFL teams that can standalone and afford the travel? I would see the travel as being a killer for that idea.

I want to be positive about the comp, however it is hard when all you hear is that you follow the AFL reserves.

Enough rambling for now.

Im with you, this year has seen a complete transition by the media treating the VFL as the AFL reserves and I dont see the the people who supposedly run the VFL doing anything about it!Unfortunately for the mob at AFL Victoria (sic) the VFA was a unique competition with many thousands of loyal club supporters who now dont attend VFL games and for good reason.
The people that now have control of the comp have little or no background in the VFA and couldnt give a stuff about its great legacy and place in the formation of our Australian Game and thats a very sad reflection on them.

Another thing is if the ABC decide to drop the VFL at any time in the future then that would be the final nail in the coffin.

The VFL wont die overnight(the poorer AFL clubs need it too much atm) but unless more people with the passion and and interest of the clubs at heart are not involved the comp will slowly fade into irrevelence and many of the clubs will either fold or join other local leagues.

vfa Mon, 27 Jul 2009 - 16:57

Reading between the lines the majority of games will be played at Coburg with a couple played at Craigieburn.
Speaking of Craigieburn who plays in the EDFL former Brunswick legend Barry 'Gabby' Nolan is the new coach of Craigieburn where the club sacked the firsts, seconds and thirds coaches. This was done about two weeks ago. Nolan will coach the club until the end of the season.

BrekkyDJ Mon, 27 Jul 2009 - 18:38

I think we (3WBC) are (subject to broadcast line) at Coburg on Saturday.

Might get the chance them to pitch the Craigieburn question at them.

CaseyRadio Mon, 27 Jul 2009 - 21:22

This question has already been raised many times during 2009

Coburg Officals have spoken strongly on this issue. With an outer training base adding new members to Richmond FC, Coburg FC is important and vital to inner northern surburban footballs survival. Coburg City Oval is a drop punt out of the city and Coburg as a football club is in a stronger position off the field now then it has been in recent years.

iceman Mon, 27 Jul 2009 - 21:23

Coburgs GM made the comment during saturdays ABC coverage that Craigeburn was well and truly on the Agenda, not to let go of Coburg and the history etc. etc. the fact that the grandstand still hadn't been fixed was frustrating etc. and that Coburg will be playing some games at Craigeburn in the future.

Can't remember a whole lot as i watched it saturday evening after the game, if i get a chance to watch it in the next couple of days again i will be more in depth.