A Barry Frankston YCW
A Beasy Frankston YCW
D Barrand ROC
S Kemperman Noble Park
B Phibbs UNKNOWN
B Murphy Glenelg
M Skehan Noble Park
C Black Somerville
L Molan Spottswood
J Hynes Edithvale/Aspendale
D Mizzi Langwarrin
C Fortnham Seaford
A Edwards Kangaroos
K Taylor Seaford
B Cadd Seaford
All these players have all had experience in the ones in the last 2 years and with maybe only J ATTARD joining Frankston from the Brisbane Lions Frankston's good year last year could be pretty hard to match with Aaron Edwards likely to be picked up by the Kangaroos in the coming draft.
Forums
To suggest that Phibbs, Black and Hynes are walk up starts to Frankstons first 22 would suggest a lack of knowledge of the Dolphins game style and what made them successful last year.
The three in question have been fine VFL players, but I know when Frankston played the team I had played for last year they ran them off their legs, and that had nothing to do with those older, slower mid fielders mentioned.
No disrespect, but I'm not sure what this means.
Do you consider Phibbs Black & Hynes walk up best 22 or not?
What you tend to forget dolphin is you can say that Black and Hynes and Cadd for that matter are not in the best 22 so why are they all ways in the team.Hynes was put in the middle on many occassions this year to stop the ball getting out of the middle and if you can remember he won the game in tassie last year by doing that and when he injured his knee against north ballarat this year he was best on ground until he went off and then Frankston got beat by 10 goals.Yes he has lost pace but experience counts for everything.Black has had more injuries than any one i know but when he was fit was always picked and if he had of stayed would of been picked again as would of Cadd as he is one of the only players at Frankston with pace and if you think he wouldnt get a game in Frankstons team for 2007 you are kidding yourself.
Another Frankston departure Chris odell who was also a former rookie at Collingwood.It is interesting to note from the 2005 list Frankston only have 14 players left on there list that played that year which is why they will never win a flag because they cant keep a side together.Chris is a huge loss to the backline.Would he make the best 22 Dolphin.
Why do I insist on answering this same garbage time & time again.
I think I might need some treatment!!
Black can't be in the best 22 if he can't get on the ground.
Hynes put all he had left in to last season. There is not another year left.
[quote:405ca3f6b1="frankstonboy"]... as would of Cadd as he is one of the only players at Frankston with pace and if you think he wouldnt get a game in Frankstons team for 2007 you are kidding yourself.[/quote]
Not much point getting the ball with your pace if 6/10 times you give it to the opposition.
Krak is a significantly better player. Just as quick, far more skilled, double the heart.
I'm not for one second saying that some of the losses at Frankston Park are not a problem, its just that you seem to think that some of the players gone are a bit more than they are.
In particular, you named Toby Conroy as being a departure when he missed the first session. You then went on to sledge him as having, as I recall, the heart of a pea.
[quote:405ca3f6b1="frankstonboy"]Another Frankston departure Chris odell who was also a former rookie at Collingwood.It is interesting to note from the 2005 list Frankston only have 14 players left on there list that played that year which is why they will never win a flag because they cant keep a side together.Chris is a huge loss to the backline.Would he make the best 22 Dolphin.[/quote]
I rate Chris as one of the best blokes I have met, but the fact that he may have been a former Collingwood Rookie is pointless.
I spent some time with Bob Skilton last week, and he is a triple Brownlow Medalist. I can assure you that he would make Frankstons list today.
At the start of last year, I didn't have COD in my best 22.
Having been dropped twice during the year thats was probably a valid call.
(Cadd actually played 8 games in the 2's. Does that reflect best 22?)
As for Chris next season, he actually wants to travel and work with Sprint Cars, which will take him away from football until about February.
Not sure what the club is supposed to do about that.
But hey, you just keep holding that little grudge of yours. You wear it so well.
Because you're easily baited!
Because you're easily baited![/quote]
Yeah, thats what I thought too.
At least I can type this crap with a cheeky grin.
Chris ODELL not in your best 22 at the start of last year Dolphin you have got to be kidding.With Mick Ablett and Ben Goddard leaving in 2005 who the hell would you play down back Mickey Mouse.I will give you a exercise to come up with your best 22 players before last year started because up until now you wouldnt of had Hynes,Black,Odell and Cadd in the side.For the record my best 22 are Eames,Phibbs,Conroy,Burns,Kennedy,Black,Hynes,ODell,Pollard,Fortnam,Edwards,Roberts,Marigliani,Winterton,Berry,Oliver,Benbow,Cadd,Mizzi,Murphy,Kemperman and Ongarello.Sorry Big Clarkey you miss out but his best has past him.Rick Morris is my Ist emergency.
Look forward in seeing your team Dolphin.
I'm so tired of your nonsence that I fail to see any reason to answer you, but it all makes perfect sense now.
For you to put Mizzi (I assume you mean Darren) in your best 22, and call Toby Conroy weak, just makes your comments worthless.
BUT, it now all makes a lot more sense.
Enjoy your time in the minor leagues son, cos you couldn't handle the heat at the top.
Mizzi! Are you serious? What did he ever do at senior level?