Fair to say the umpiring in two of the three TAC Cup games yesterday at Bendigo was disgusting.

However what was disappointing is the quality of the bouncing by the umpires. I'm all for the recall policy, but unfortunately at lower levels of footy where the umpires are no where near as talented at it and are more often than not dealing with rough surfaces, cricket wickets and the like they're going to make mistakes.

We had conservatively a dozen recalls in one game, it got to the point that they waved some as play on despite them being more crooked than ones earlier in the game that were recalled. It was embarrassing.

I'm not sure whether we've had issues in the VFL at this stage, perhaps the better bouncers are in charge of that competition. However, we can't see incidents like today's continue through the year.

If we find a strike rate of recalls to be too high, what do we do? Should the VFL/TAC adopt a ball up policy?

MinkaBeaver Sun, 19 Apr 2009 - 00:32

footyman wrote:Fair to say the umpiring in two of the three TAC Cup games yesterday at Bendigo was disgusting.

However what was disappointing is the quality of the bouncing by the umpires. I'm all for the recall policy, but unfortunately at lower levels of footy where the umpires are no where near as talented at it and are more often than not dealing with rough surfaces, cricket wickets and the like they're going to make mistakes.

We had conservatively a dozen recalls in one game, it got to the point that they waved some as play on despite them being more crooked than ones earlier in the game that were recalled. It was embarrassing.

I'm not sure whether we've had issues in the VFL at this stage, perhaps the better bouncers are in charge of that competition. However, we can't see incidents like today's continue through the year.

If we find a strike rate of recalls to be too high, what do we do? Should the VFL/TAC adopt a ball up policy?

For reasons too long (and boring) to go into, the bounce matters to me - this is the only sport I know of where the officials need to perform a physical skill. So much else that's unique is being lost from the game that it's worth fighting for the things that remain.

At Carlton today, perhaps five centre bounces were recalled. I don't like the rule anyway, but in some cases the bounces weren't even that bad. It's a rule that has opened up a can of worms.

Chatting to one of the emerging umpires last year, he said that you can't progress very far at all unless you bounce the ball well.

footyman Topic starter Sun, 19 Apr 2009 - 00:40

MinkaBeaver wrote:At Carlton today, perhaps five centre bounces were recalled.

I think 5 is too many!!!!

It seems the rule is if the ball would land outside of the larger centre circle then the ball is recalled. Perhaps you're right, we should have them only recall absolute shockers (ala the one at the MCG last year Collingwood v Kangaroos).

I'm in favour now of canning the bounce at VFL/TAC level.
What I saw today was embarrassing. It slows the game up too much.

As for good bouncers getting the jobs with the VFL...I'd rather see good decision makers and people who understand the game out there in orange.

MinkaBeaver Sun, 19 Apr 2009 - 00:54

footyman wrote:It seems the rule is if the ball would land outside of the larger centre circle then the ball is recalled. Perhaps you're right, we should have them only recall absolute shockers (ala the one at the MCG last year Collingwood v Kangaroos).

I'm in favour now of canning the bounce at VFL/TAC level.
What I saw today was embarrassing. It slows the game up too much.

As for good bouncers getting the jobs with the VFL...I'd rather see good decision makers and people who understand the game out there in orange.

Everyone wants to see good decision makers, but unfortunately the reason so many take up umpiring is because they are physically unable/unwilling to play the game at any early age. And with modern umpiring, to make it far you generally need to start as a kid.

One of the best umpires of all time was Peter Carey. He played the game right up until the age of about 21. How many modern umpires have that background? How many can empathise with the players?

We need to ask too whether three field umpires has been beneficial for the game. There are three different takes on what is a very subjective game to adjudicate, and often from officials who don't work together each week.

Increasingly too it seems that umpires are pulling out free kicks when they are blind sided from the play or well away from the contest - how often do we see umpires who are 50, 70, 80 metres from the play pull out free kicks when the umpire closest to the action has seen it fit to let play continue? How many of those decisions are correct?

InForAPenny Sun, 19 Apr 2009 - 07:24

I was at Princes Park like Minkabeaver. I reckon he's conservative on the 5 times. I would have thought it was 7 or 8. It was certainly annoying when some were recalled that were better than others that were not recalled.

I didn't specifically look at the centre circle but in general the surface there was very good.

MinkaBeaver Sun, 19 Apr 2009 - 11:20

InForAPenny wrote:I was at Princes Park like Minkabeaver. I reckon he's conservative on the 5 times. I would have thought it was 7 or 8. It was certainly annoying when some were recalled that were better than others that were not recalled.

I didn't specifically look at the centre circle but in general the surface there was very good.

The centre circle was extremely sandy - not a blade of grass. Still, it had been compacted and looked firm.

In any case, your observations confirm my thoughts - there were a heap of recalls!

I hasten to add that many of them were bounces that the umpires could probably have got away with under the current rules, but they are being very radical in their interpretation of it at the moment.

footyman Topic starter Sun, 19 Apr 2009 - 17:36

I agree with all you've written Minka, but the biggest problem is that to be an umpire at VFL/TAC level you need good endurance. Which means we're seeing an influx of young umpires because at the end of the day these guys are the only ones capable of running all day. You go and watch an Ammos game, or a local footy game or a school footy game and often you'll see at least one umpire who is aged 40+ with a bit of a belly and mostly they walk around.

But with youth comes major inexperience. And those umpires who start in their early 20s in this competition often furiate us for a few years and by the time they are any good, we lose them to the AFL!

AkiBerg Fri, 24 Apr 2009 - 13:57

The rule changes and bonkers stuff they have to ajudicate on now isn't helping one bit.

bcarbonaro Mon, 27 Apr 2009 - 00:49

Absolutely true, I don't think everyone appreciates just how hard it is to umpire at the highest level.

footyman Topic starter Mon, 27 Apr 2009 - 09:16

Benny C, taking the official's viewpoint again.

It's alright to knock them buddy!!!

They're crap, so is that turd Gieschen...and you only have to read today's Herald Sun to see how bad the bouncing issue is!!

bcarbonaro Mon, 27 Apr 2009 - 23:32

footyman wrote:Benny C, taking the official's viewpoint again.

It's alright to knock them buddy!!!

They're crap, so is that turd Gieschen...and you only have to read today's Herald Sun to see how bad the bouncing issue is!!

I have a mate who was on the VFL panel, he did TAC Cup and reserves I have an appreciation/understaning of how hard it is to umpire at the highest level.

In most cases, I think that umpire bashing isn't on.