Vfl clubs who still have members & supporters unaffiliated with their afl club

Hey everyone

Im just interested on peoples thoughts on who they think has the most "true" supporters.

Port would more than likley be most peoples #1 i think?
Who in your opinion has the least support/attendance at games?

If any club was to lose their afl affiliation which club would fall flat on its arse the worst?

StationHotel Thu, 9 May 2013 - 20:43

it's also up to current clubs

I would be sifting out old membership contacts emailing and calling them to jump on board if they currently not a member i couldn't say if this has been happening ?

MegaA Thu, 9 May 2013 - 22:03

In reply to by burraburger

I'm prety much one of those people that your talking about when you say "they dont have a AFL team but follow the borough". In my work I often meet people and the topic of football always comes up. People often ask - who do you go for and I say Carlton but I love Port Melbourne. I'm always saying I would give away 10 of the Carlton premierships for one Port premiership.

Most people are here agree port is the best supported club in the league. That must be pretty sad for the league then. Thats not realy positive stuff as Port probably had 1000 at their 1st game at North Port last weekend. If Port had 1000 people at their 1st game at home after beating the undefeated blues a week earlier then what are other clubs getting through the gates, clubs that are struggling on field ??? 200 ? 300 ?

By the sounds of it some of the clubs are not getting much more people attend then your local suburban match. Considering the league is the 2nd best league (arguably) and considering that Victorians are crazy about their footabll(almost like a religion), then I think that its fair to say the crowds are poor. Each club should be averaging at least 2k.

billythekid Thu, 9 May 2013 - 23:15

Yep we have been down this track many times and I dont think the VFL crowds are getting any bigger maybe that have actually gone down over the past few seasons.

Port get about as many as a good VFA thirds game did years ago and I dont see any reason for the crowds too come back and yes I have seen much bigger crowds at local leagues.

As for cars at the grounds it gives a hicksville look and the VFA stopped cars around the boundry in the 1970s due to safety fears of having a car crush people against the fence so Im surprised its still being allowed at the supposed # 2 league in Victoria.

Maybe Workcover should have another look!

riccardo Fri, 10 May 2013 - 08:42

I;m the same as MegaA, when anyone asks I say I barrack for St Kilda but I follow Port. I haven't even been to an AFL game this year because, as far as I'm concerned, its more theater than actual footy these days. I still have memberships for both clubs, but if forced to choose, I'd be at North Port over Docklands any day of the week!

MegaA Fri, 10 May 2013 - 12:57

Perhaps if you feel that strong about Port over St kilda then you hold off buying a St kilda membership (i'm sur ethey will be ok) and put that money towards Port!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

burraburger Sat, 11 May 2013 - 11:07

Just on crowd attendance, the past 5 years when Port have played Sandringham at Sandringham the crowds have been fantastic and what we normally get during finals time.
One thing that hasnt charged is that crowds are always bigger on sundays. No clash with local footy and many young people dont have sporting commitments.

Borough1874 Topic starter Sat, 11 May 2013 - 12:20

How good would it be if the if they ever made 2 divisions (afl clubs & vfa clubs)
That the afl stand alone's all played on a Saturday (be best to allow for recovery time) & all the vfa clubs played on a Sunday.

Preston was chockers v port. It's all about finding what suits their demographic of supporter base.
Sundays worked with frankston. Although I do hear lots of port supporters who dislike the Sunday games.

ravenxau Sat, 11 May 2013 - 13:12

In reply to by Borough1874

As I rely on public transport to get to the footy, Sunday games would make attending the games a lot more difficult - but I do see the validity of the split into 2 divisions.

ravenxau Sat, 11 May 2013 - 13:24

In reply to by Borough1874

As I rely on public transport to get to the footy, Sunday games would make attending the games a lot more difficult - but I do see the validity of the split into 2 divisions.

burraburger Sat, 11 May 2013 - 15:32

So many people work on saturdays (hairdressers, retail, hospitailty etc) and this is the main day of trade for many businesses. This cant be underestimated as a genuine reason why crowds arnt as big on a saturday.
Generally sunday is a day of lesuire and the one day people have little or no commitments.
The one huge negative of a stand alone VFL team playing sunday's is that the players lose their whole weekend and cant really do much on a friday and saturday night.
People have said in the past saturday games are better for the players to recover but if every game is a sunday they get a 7 day break anyway.