Official discussion thread!

I was hoping Werribee would make it through for the good of the competition, as they still appear to be a club in their own right, whereas Box Hill really aren't their own club anymore with the jumper change, song change and name change etc.

Still it might bring a bigger crowd along or it could work against the VFL, with general supporters less likely to attend a 'reserves' Grand Final.

From what I saw of todays game, it's difficult to see the Hawks really challenging Geelong. I wonder what impact Friday nights game between the two clubs will have on selection.

billythekid Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 12:14

In reply to by riccardo

The only way a VFL GF would get anywhere near that crowd figure is if the AFL media dept pushed the papers and shows like the Footy Show to promote the match

Ch7 wont as they see the ABC as competition.
The VFL way back in the 1960s had a standalone Seconds GF at the G a week after the main GF due to a draw and from memory it was ST Kilda V Essendon and they only got 17,000 when footy was god.

Sunday may get 20,000 plus but I doubt it.

vfa Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 13:48

Crowd 15,000 at max.
If the cats win on Friday night Geelong will beat Box Hill by 14 goals.
If Hawthorn win on Friday then Geelong will win by 8 goals instead of 14 goals.
For me being an old VFA supporter I rate the personal interest in this game as care factor zero. Geelong reserves v Hawthorn reserves. I have been going to GFs since the Max Papley days. Will meet up at the Great Western Hotel before the game. Will probably spend most of the third quarter in the Locker Room bar.

Wally from Wil… Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 15:09

In reply to by blackrocker

blackrocker wrote:

The only remanent of the VFA that remains in this GF is the White Horse on Box Hills jumper.

Peter Donegan even referred to Box Hill as Hawthorn early in yesterday's broadcast. He repeated the comment later but called them Box Hill the second time. The white horse is also VERY small on the jumper.

Wally from Wil… Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 15:13

In reply to by billythekid

billythekid wrote:

The only way a VFL GF would get anywhere near that crowd figure is if the AFL media dept pushed the papers and shows like the Footy Show to promote the match

Ch7 wont as they see the ABC as competition.

The VFL way back in the 1960s had a standalone Seconds GF at the G a week after the main GF due to a draw and from memory it was ST Kilda V Essendon and they only got 17,000 when footy was god.

Sunday may get 20,000 plus but I doubt it.

Channel 7 didn't even mention the VFL during the sports report last night, at least Channel 9 had a snippet of vision & gave the result & the opponents for next week's GF.

Borough1874 Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 15:17

I'm
Surprised no afl/vfl flog has not mentioned

" why not play this game as a curtain raiser to the afl prelim final."

comeng Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 19:34

In reply to by vfa

vfa wrote:

Crowd 15,000 at max.

If the cats win on Friday night Geelong will beat Box Hill by 14 goals.

If Hawthorn win on Friday then Geelong will win by 8 goals instead of 14 goals.

For me being an old VFA supporter I rate the personal interest in this game as care factor zero. Geelong reserves v Hawthorn reserves. I have been going to GFs since the Max Papley days. Will meet up at the Great Western Hotel before the game. Will probably spend most of the third quarter in the Locker Room bar.

With more and more AFL reserves teams joining the VFL the sooner it is split into two conferences the better. The conference system I have in mind is:
- 2 Conferences. VFL and VFA.
- Teams play each team in their own conference once. Remaining games in the season are inter-conference games
- Teams in the VFA conference must field a team in the Development league
- Final four in each conference
- A championship game for each conference is played at the time the prelims are played now
- The VFA and VFL conference champions will play each other in the AFL Victoria championship a week after the AFL GF.

As for the game, it is really care factor zero. I might watch it or if the weather is OK I might take my son to the park.

cobrascorer Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 23:19

In reply to by Wally from Wil…

There were at least two references to Box Hill as Hawthorn. But can anyone blame commentators when "Box Hill" looks so much like its controller's outfit? I wonder how much longer will the tiny White Horse be allowed to stay on the jumper.

vfa Mon, 16 Sep 2013 - 23:30

You will see the Whitehorse on the Box Hill jumper about as often as you would see a hotel in Box Hill.
The last Hotel in Box hill was called the Whitehorse Hotel and was closed in the early 40s.