I think you guys need to realise that the VFL is the AFL Victoria Reserves competition, with a few standalones, and that is how it is. It will never be the VFA of old, as there aren't enough viable clubs, and as we saw with Bendigo last year, the AFL or VFL for that matter, don't care about its clubs at all, otherwise they would have actually helped.
As for McEvoy, he is a Hawthorn/Box Hill listed player. Hawthorn were still in the AFL finals, so he is eligible for the VFL finals. The only restriction should be if said player has played more than 10 games in the AFL, then he shouldn't be able to drop back to VFL for finals. Dunno if McEvoy had played that many? If he did, he shouldn't have been able to play.
Even if he hadn't played any games for Box Hill all season, and played 9 for Hawthorn, he should still be eligible for Box Hill finals, because Box Hill is actually Hawthorn FC reserves, and that is the way it should be treated.
I understand this will rile most of you, but without the AFL clubs, they could form a VFA, but it'd be rubbish footy compared to what it is now, because the pokie-driven clubs would dominate, and money will just ruin it all.
I think you guys need to realise that the VFL is the AFL Victoria Reserves competition, with a few standalones, and that is how it is. It will never be the VFA of old, as there aren't enough viable clubs, and as we saw with Bendigo last year, the AFL or VFL for that matter, don't care about its clubs at all, otherwise they would have actually helped.
As for McEvoy, he is a Hawthorn/Box Hill listed player. Hawthorn were still in the AFL finals, so he is eligible for the VFL finals. The only restriction should be if said player has played more than 10 games in the AFL, then he shouldn't be able to drop back to VFL for finals. Dunno if McEvoy had played that many? If he did, he shouldn't have been able to play.
Even if he hadn't played any games for Box Hill all season, and played 9 for Hawthorn, he should still be eligible for Box Hill finals, because Box Hill is actually Hawthorn FC reserves, and that is the way it should be treated.
I understand this will rile most of you, but without the AFL clubs, they could form a VFA, but it'd be rubbish footy compared to what it is now, because the pokie-driven clubs would dominate, and money will just ruin it all.
All pretty fair points Goldie, but NOT ALL clubs are prepared to waste their money gained from pokie machines on dud footballers.
I think you guys need to realise that the VFL is the AFL Victoria Reserves competition, with a few standalones, and that is how it is. It will never be the VFA of old, as there aren't enough viable clubs, and as we saw with Bendigo last year, the AFL or VFL for that matter, don't care about its clubs at all, otherwise they would have actually helped.
As for McEvoy, he is a Hawthorn/Box Hill listed player. Hawthorn were still in the AFL finals, so he is eligible for the VFL finals. The only restriction should be if said player has played more than 10 games in the AFL, then he shouldn't be able to drop back to VFL for finals. Dunno if McEvoy had played that many? If he did, he shouldn't have been able to play.
Even if he hadn't played any games for Box Hill all season, and played 9 for Hawthorn, he should still be eligible for Box Hill finals, because Box Hill is actually Hawthorn FC reserves, and that is the way it should be treated.
I understand this will rile most of you, but without the AFL clubs, they could form a VFA, but it'd be rubbish footy compared to what it is now, because the pokie-driven clubs would dominate, and money will just ruin it all.
In reply to I think you guys need to by Gold
All pretty fair points Goldie, but NOT ALL clubs are prepared to waste their money gained from pokie machines on dud footballers.
I think Goldie has got a few different issues rolled into one. Is this rule change only applicable to senior VFL games?
Pagination