Can anybody give me a good reason why the VFL wont increase the salary cap for this competition???? The VFL have said they want some stand alone teams but in all honesty what chance is there that a stand alone team will win the premiership?
How can teams like Port and Frankston recruit with so little money?? All that happens each season is clubs begin to build a squad that they think can make the finals. But after recruiting a handfull of quality players the money runs out because of the tiny salary cap.
Lets look at Williamstown as an example... most weeks they have between 12-16 AFL listed players that salaries do not come under the salary cap as they are on an AFL list.
So really all the Willy footy club need is 6-8 players that they can splurge money on to make up the rest of the team.
Now look at a team like Port or Frankston. Every player basically comes under the salary cap so the money is divided into a minimum of 22 players.
That is chicken feed and its no wonder the stand alone are up against it.
Id love to see the VFL make the salary cap open slather or at least dramatically increase it. Reward the clubs for having money in the bank and running a sucessful business.
What does everyone think??????
Making open slather runs the risk of running clubs completely dry, can be very dangerous. If Port and Frankston can perhaps come up with a Value that they both feel they are able to support financially as well as creating competitive teams then i say they should look into it.
Why do I say just Port and Frankson?? becasue if you, say, put it too a vote, of course the aligned clubs are gonna want the Salary cap to stay the same for them, as it increases their own chance at finishing higher.
What we need is clubs to be able to have pulling power in more ways than immediate finances, I mean clubs should be able to offer things like job opportunities, education opportunities through sponsors and networking to give players more of a reason to move to an area to play footy.
On top of this I think in the long term, the closer relationship of VFL/TAC clubs will enable more of a club feeling with junior footballers, and therefore hopefully creat a 'home' for a player if they play at a higher level for a period of time. You are more likely to get an ex AFL player who played 'juniors' with your club, and still has the blokes he went through with, then one who he has no emotional connection whatsoever.
Can anyone remeber the rules put in place for recruiting interstate players back home and % being outside the cap etc?? that was a good step, but can be very short term. We need the pulling power to attract Marquee players into the comp. See the response Buckley got last weekend?? I wouldn't think Buckley would consider playing VFL football after retirement, but other 'elite' players might, if opportunities were there for carrer pathways. Some people will follow player just to watch them go about their stuff regardless of where they play. Perhaps say 1 or 2 'Marquee' players outside the cap?? similar to the A-League soccer??
but then we run into another hurdle with alignments, I know an AFL listed player from last season who was delisted, and when weighing up VFL, SANFL and WAFL, believe it or not, it wasn't the money that pulled him to the SANFL, it was education opportunities, and on top of that, and what he felt had a major impact, he wanted to go to a club that still had the 'heart' in it, this season, as much as we hate to say it, their are 11 clubs that don't, or at least that is the perception. On top of this, being a loyal person, dind't want to go to another VFL club from his AFL aligned one, as it seemed unloyal, however saw how much the AFL club dictated the VFL club. and didn't see opportunities there.
Things need to be done for the long term, currently the VFL seems to be here just because it is, and that it.