Do you think that the VFL next year needs to really consider what to do with this rule. If it is to remain then should it be for all games no matter who is playing who. I think the up & down perfomanace of some clubs is caused by the number of changes Clubs need to make to accommodate this rule each week. Some clubs are not selecting their best teams each week becasue of the rule and I know that for a fact. It is also very unsettling for many VFL listed players with them knowing that although they may play well in the ones on one day they may be out the following week if AFL Listed players are due back into team. With AFL lists talked about being raised to 46 next year with 2 extra rookies being added will make the selection harder. The flow AFL listed players into the VFL seconds are making some of those games a complete joke and not good for VFL Footy
vfa Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 09:28
I agree that the 12/10 rule should be kept all year round including finals. Nothing worse than seeing 17 or 18 afl listed players like Geelong have been doing in the past. Speaking of that it was great to see the two AFL stand alone teams Geelong (get slaughtered by North Ballarat 132points) and Collingwood (back to the bottom). Always great to see that of stand alone AFL CRAP !!!!!!