TAKEN FROM ANOTHER THREAD
cobrascorer wrote:It was very annoying on Sat 12 & 19 July to hear frequent mentions of "seniors" meaning AFL sides. VFL teams ARE seniors. Players do not go to the "seniors" if going from a VFL team to an AFL team. They are going to an AFL team - the AFL clubs have only one team. They are not the "seniors". This sort of demeaning attitude is expected from AFL ignoramuses, but surely we can expect VFL commentators to get it right.
If AFL listed players are playing at VFL level, that is one below the highest level they could be playing, hence being below the seniors. If a VFL player is running around in the reserves, he is therefore playing at one-level below the highest level he could be playing. AFL Players mindset - Seniors (AFL Club) - Reserves (VFL club) - Thirds (VFL reserves) VFL Players mindset - Seniors (VFL Club) - Reserves (VFL reserves) - Thirds (Local Club) It's simple, that's exactly what the current landscape dictates to footy followers, the VFL commentators are correct, if you want to spread lies and not face up to the truth run for president in Zimbabwe or join ASIO. If you get dropped from an AFL side you don't go from the seniors to the seniors, that's just ridiculous. Denying this obvious feature of the modern-day footballing structure and pathway is preposterous and utter non-sense. It’s fantastic that people want to the keep historical legacy of the VFA alive, it’s also great to see the competition thriving on the field. The talent and class on display every weekend from most clubs rates in the top echelon of footy played around the nation, and is something to behold. Supporters from the past VFA need to move forward and form a unified front for the VFL to survive and prosper – negativity and spite will do none of this. Get with the times, have a crack, make a difference – in a huge manner.
footyman Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 16:54
You're calling a game of footy in the VFL competition, hence when you refer to reserves and seniors you should be referring to the levels of footy within the competition. At half time on your coverage you dont give out the "seniors scores", you refer to it as the AFL. It is an entirely different competition and should be labelled as such. Where an AFL listed player is dropped, he is moving into another competition. In that case you should say "x has been dropped from the AFL", or alternatively "y has been promoted to the AFL". It's really not that hard.
TheVoiceoftheB Topic starter Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 17:46
footyman wrote:You're calling a game of footy in the VFL competition, hence when you refer to reserves and seniors you should be referring to the levels of footy within the competition. At half time on your coverage you dont give out the "seniors scores", you refer to it as the AFL. It is an entirely different competition and should be labelled as such. Where an AFL listed player is dropped, he is moving into another competition. In that case you should say "x has been dropped from the AFL", or alternatively "y has been promoted to the AFL". It's really not that hard.
Do you at least accept Geelong and Collingwood as reserves?
footyman Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 18:00
TheVoiceoftheB wrote:Do you at least accept Geelong and Collingwood as reserves?
No. To me they're the Geelong and Collingwood VFL sides.
TheVoiceoftheB Topic starter Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 18:38
footyman wrote:[quote:4baf258990="TheVoiceoftheB"] Do you at least accept Geelong and Collingwood as reserves?
No. To me they're the Geelong and Collingwood VFL sides.[/quote] Still holding on to history won't get anyone anywhere it seems, they do play some local league players but face-it most weeks they play 14-18 AFL players, the VFL is there seconds, there's no to way's about it. From me VFL and AFL will be avoided when commentating, clubs will be named instead, to the best of our ability. The new younger blokes will still call the VFL sides the seconds, they don't know any better. Most support for the VFL, via crowd numbers comes via the AFL alignments anyway, they all view the VFL as the seconds. But I'm stickin' with promoted and dropped.
vfa Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 18:54
What about Frankston, Port and Tassie. Are they reserves ? What about Justin Crow a vfl listed player for Collingwood, is he a reserves player ? It is a senior comp. Will Port Melbourne if they win this years flag be called reserves premiers ? Get real will you. Would you ever see someone calling Port Adelaide Magpies player Jer3emy Clayton playing senior footy for Port saying he is playing reserves football for Port firsts ?
footyman Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 18:55
I'm not a heck of a lot older than you or any of the 'young blokes' you have calling with you. And I'm hardly a nazi when it comes to blasting people slapping the VFL with the reserves tag because sadly too many people nowadays do it that I just let it go. But I believe we should respect the history of these clubs and the competition which most of these sides have come from, even if it is not labelled the VFA anymore and refer to the competition they play in as the VFL. I reckon that is fair enough and not hard to refer to Geelong and Collingwood as their VFL side. But you're probably right that the left over Geelong AFL listed players are essentially their reserves, but it is easy to avoid using that terminology IMO.
TheVoiceoftheB Topic starter Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 19:58
vfa wrote:What about Frankston, Port and Tassie. Are they reserves ? What about Justin Crow a vfl listed player for Collingwood, is he a reserves player ? It is a senior comp. Will Port Melbourne if they win this years flag be called reserves premiers ? Get real will you. Would you ever see someone calling Port Adelaide Magpies player Jer3emy Clayton playing senior footy for Port saying he is playing reserves football for Port firsts ?
[quote:4657a9f66a="TheVoiceoftheB"]AFL Players mindset - Seniors (AFL Club) - Reserves (VFL club) - Thirds (VFL reserves) VFL Players mindset - Seniors (VFL Club) - Reserves (VFL reserves) - Thirds (Local Club)[/quote] That answers your question, it's above. Ofcourse Port, Frankston and Tassie are different as are Geelong and Collingwood. Do all of the old VFA fans support either Frankston or Port Melbourne? They should.
NorthPort Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 20:32
I'm with Footyman on this one, please refer to being promoted or dropped as AFL/VFL/VFL reserves. As a VFL supporter, if I hear someone is dropped to the 'twos' it refers to the VFL Reserves, not the senior VFL competition. The Victorian Football League has enough of an identity crisis as it is, it doesn't need it's radio coverage perpetuating this problem.
Gouloff Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 21:18
I can understand it from both sides if you're a player such as Adam Simpson, Brad Sewell, Adam Cooney or even a Gary Ablett the VFL is certainly the 'reserves' but the great VFL players such as Robin Nahas, Brett Goodes, Nick Sautner or James Byrne the VFL is the seniors but you can't expect everyone to call them the same thing when percieved from either side the fence but hey there needs to be some clarity on what to call it.