TAKEN FROM ANOTHER THREAD
cobrascorer wrote:It was very annoying on Sat 12 & 19 July to hear frequent mentions of "seniors" meaning AFL sides. VFL teams ARE seniors. Players do not go to the "seniors" if going from a VFL team to an AFL team. They are going to an AFL team - the AFL clubs have only one team. They are not the "seniors". This sort of demeaning attitude is expected from AFL ignoramuses, but surely we can expect VFL commentators to get it right.
If AFL listed players are playing at VFL level, that is one below the highest level they could be playing, hence being below the seniors. If a VFL player is running around in the reserves, he is therefore playing at one-level below the highest level he could be playing. AFL Players mindset - Seniors (AFL Club) - Reserves (VFL club) - Thirds (VFL reserves) VFL Players mindset - Seniors (VFL Club) - Reserves (VFL reserves) - Thirds (Local Club) It's simple, that's exactly what the current landscape dictates to footy followers, the VFL commentators are correct, if you want to spread lies and not face up to the truth run for president in Zimbabwe or join ASIO. If you get dropped from an AFL side you don't go from the seniors to the seniors, that's just ridiculous. Denying this obvious feature of the modern-day footballing structure and pathway is preposterous and utter non-sense. It’s fantastic that people want to the keep historical legacy of the VFA alive, it’s also great to see the competition thriving on the field. The talent and class on display every weekend from most clubs rates in the top echelon of footy played around the nation, and is something to behold. Supporters from the past VFA need to move forward and form a unified front for the VFL to survive and prosper – negativity and spite will do none of this. Get with the times, have a crack, make a difference – in a huge manner.
NorthPort Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 21:27
Gouloff wrote:I can understand it from both sides if you're a player such as Adam Simpson, Brad Sewell, Adam Cooney or even a Gary Ablett the VFL is certainly the 'reserves' but the great VFL players such as Robin Nahas, Brett Goodes, Nick Sautner or James Byrne the VFL is the seniors but you can't expect everyone to call them the same thing when percieved from either side the fence but hey there needs to be some clarity on what to call it.
Thats why you call it the AFL, the VFL, or the VFL Reserves, to avoid that altogether.
Gouloff Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 21:34
NorthPort wrote:[quote:b61e97c57a="Gouloff"]I can understand it from both sides if you're a player such as Adam Simpson, Brad Sewell, Adam Cooney or even a Gary Ablett the VFL is certainly the 'reserves' but the great VFL players such as Robin Nahas, Brett Goodes, Nick Sautner or James Byrne the VFL is the seniors but you can't expect everyone to call them the same thing when percieved from either side the fence but hey there needs to be some clarity on what to call it.
Thats why you call it the AFL, the VFL, or the VFL Reserves, to avoid that altogether.[/quote] But when you've played local footy from a kid your told the best you can play in is the seniors then being dropped is the reserves, so your going to have to change how they're raised
billythekid Mon, 21 Jul 2008 - 21:42
TheVoiceoftheB wrote:TAKEN FROM ANOTHER THREAD [quote:b826c2281c="cobrascorer"]It was very annoying on Sat 12 & 19 July to hear frequent mentions of "seniors" meaning AFL sides. VFL teams ARE seniors. Players do not go to the "seniors" if going from a VFL team to an AFL team. They are going to an AFL team - the AFL clubs have only one team. They are not the "seniors". This sort of demeaning attitude is expected from AFL ignoramuses, but surely we can expect VFL commentators to get it right.
If AFL listed players are playing at VFL level, that is one below the highest level they could be playing, hence being below the seniors. If a VFL player is running around in the reserves, he is therefore playing at one-level below the highest level he could be playing. AFL Players mindset - Seniors (AFL Club) - Reserves (VFL club) - Thirds (VFL reserves) VFL Players mindset - Seniors (VFL Club) - Reserves (VFL reserves) - Thirds (Local Club) It's simple, that's exactly what the current landscape dictates to footy followers, the VFL commentators are correct, if you want to spread lies and not face up to the truth run for president in Zimbabwe or join ASIO. If you get dropped from an AFL side you don't go from the seniors to the seniors, that's just ridiculous. Denying this obvious feature of the modern-day footballing structure and pathway is preposterous and utter non-sense. It’s fantastic that people want to the keep historical legacy of the VFA alive, it’s also great to see the competition thriving on the field. The talent and class on display every weekend from most clubs rates in the top echelon of footy played around the nation, and is something to behold. Supporters from the past VFA need to move forward and form a unified front for the VFL to survive and prosper – negativity and spite will do none of this. Get with the times, have a crack, make a difference – in a huge manner.[/quote] The competition "thriving" you have to JOKING! When you deny your past you have NO FUTURE! Throughout their history the VFL and now AFL Clubs have tried to deny their VFA early history and were always intent on destroying the VFA image as it didnt suit their view of history. The current bastardised VFL (sic) is going nowhere fast and all your uneducated pathetic pleading will not make its slow demise and death as a respected sporting organisation in its own right from happening. Go to most games and the crowd would be lucky to as good as the VFA Thirds used to get. Once a made up competition like the VFL loses the respect of the public which it has then it has no future. Its only a matter of time when the AFL take over and run it as the Reserves. BTW most AFL supporters or Media have little or no interest in the "VFL" or its teams.You only have to see the shocking crowds at Collingwood reserves home games to to see that. IF you dont believe me you just have to look at the current video of the Willy vs Coburg game and you will see how bad the crowds have become. Without the AFL and their clubs propping up the Comp it would fold over night - a sad but true fact.
CaseyRadio Tue, 22 Jul 2008 - 00:09
I consider myself still young at 26.. and have been broadcasting this competition now for 6 years. It is disrespectful to the VFL Listed Players in any side including Collingwood and Geelong!! To call this quality competition the 'AFL' Reserves. When a player 'drops back' to the VFL it should never be referred to as the ''seconds''. Have a conversation with the geniune VFL public, the guys who experienced the glory days and think how lucky they were to go down on a Sunday with 10,000 mates and watch some biff and quality footy.. The stories from these days can overshadow highlights created at a higher level, to refer to their history as the 'reserves' is a disgrace Yeah a lot of this history is VFA related and many traditional folk would like to see it back this way!! The VFA turned to the VFL for survival, modern day life absurd the VFA. When the VFL aligned itself with AFL clubs the landscape changed forever... It doesnt matter what age you are its how you look at what your going to see. My real following of this comp came when the alignments were shaping some growing stronger some fading in memory... Does anyone remember the Murray Kangaroos?? I cant reflect to some of the glory days.. but when you speak to anyone of interest at the footy and start to reflect you can just see what these memories mean to people.. It was some of the best days of their life. We should respect this and promote the great competition we have As a youngster my memories of going to the footy was getting their early each day of the weekend, at the 'G, being early didnt matter but we had the reserves. Its an easy cop out to call the VFL the 'reserves'.. Just look at the players who started at VFL Clubs before being drafted or rookied!! Ask AFL Vic Media if they want the broadcasters referring to this as the reserves?? I try my best to never do this!! Last week I referred to a Geary goal as a great one by a young Saint!! I felt like slapping myself!!
vfa Tue, 22 Jul 2008 - 10:32
It should have never ever been called the vfl. It should always be called the vfa as the afl was the vfl. The idiots who decided to call the comp the vfl are tools. I still call it the VFA. Why call it the vfl, is it to try erase all history from 1877 ? Also when referring to premierships all 2nd Division flags should be counted as they are senior flags !!!! As for the reserves tag in a senior comp, you would never ever hear that from the wafl or sanfl would you ??? Get over afl stooge mentality and give credit to all footballers playing in the vfl (I will call it VFA) seniors comp that they are playing seniors !!!!
STANGA Tue, 22 Jul 2008 - 17:53
We all still call VFL the VFA usually, i refer to the mustangs, footscray and north melbourne (changed back now), Kardinia Park, North Port Oval etc., some things are just hard to change. I'm only 26 (27 on satday) too, and started following the comp properly about '94-'95, but always had a fair idea about it. I definitlely didn't see the "glory days", but looking back just to the mid '90's, it seems it was a lot purer or something only back then! Should definitely be called either the vfa or something to encorporate the old association name, the VFL was simply a lazy, lazy, choice when looking to re-brand. I'm not a fan of it at all, but the A-League has done well with it's name and marketing, but don't tell head office or they'll call it V-League! What are some branding issues/solutions. (Apart from reserves tag! Already covered!)