More patience will be needed for Dolphins supporters in 2023. Despite the club sending a video out last year of Danny Ryan banging on about how aggressive recruiting will be and talking finals, the club hasnt really come up with much. Minchin from Glenelg via Vermont, Seb Quirk who played 10 VFL games for GWS and Chayce Black  who was on Box Hill VFL list for 2 years but didnt get a game appear to be the best. 

Outs

Begley, Reidy, Newman, Arthurson, Fletcher, Hiscock, McKay, Murphy, 

McLaughlin training with Gold Coast and Turner training with Melbourne may also be lost.

aj9172 Fri, 27 Jan 2023 - 17:11

Too late to break away from the AFL now I imagine? I'd love to see the remaining clubs do that and invite half a dozen of the strongest suburban clubs to form a new VFA. I'm imagining the cost of doing so would sink all but 3 of the remaining clubs and probably not be sustainable for long anyway. There is just such a feeling of hopelessness for the competition now (not just talking as a Frankston supporter either). It makes me feel sick to think of all the hard work and sacrifice people have made to resurrect my club, only to see us in a position where we still can't retain a decent playing group regardless of our financial position. There seems to be no doubt that the AFL want this competition to remain ONLY to provide a reserves competition for the league. How do supporters of the other standalones feel about the future? I'd be intrigued to see where everyone thinks we're headed.

digs Fri, 27 Jan 2023 - 17:35

Main comment in country football is how come many established country players are all heading to Barwon Heads for 2023.Obviously the salary cap is not a problem down there & many are pointing the finger at an old Williamstown identity. 

Surely not !

 

 

MegaA Thu, 2 Feb 2023 - 22:01

In reply to by aj9172

In response to your question, I can see the competition merits and its downside. For the positive, having the competition in its current form gives our stand alone clubs a amount of exposure that they certainly wouldn't get if they played in a comp without the AFL clubs. I like the fact that Port Melbourne can play let's say Collingwood and potentially have over 50,000 tv viewers, I like the fact that games are on free to air. I also like that it gives it that bit of spark that when I go to work I can make mention of my side playing against other workmates vfl sides. Admittedly they generally don't overly care and it's no surprise as it's their 2nds side but it does for a moment create some talk and interest and our clubs can have some workplace banter that they wouldn't otherwise get. Having the AFL clubs included gives the competition a little bit more excitement, better crowds, facilities, playing standard and media attention but let's not fool ourselves it definitely has its negativities as well which as you said AJ is that the AFL only sees and treats it as a reserves competition for AFL clubs. It was a big kick in the guts when they got rid of the reserves and a few years later demanded 6 players under the age of 22 play each week. Those rules showed total disregard to the feedback of the stand alone clubs and a lack of care, which for all fans and clubs the amount of involvement by the AFL in the running of our great clubs is extremely frustrating. What about the mid season draft where any player of any stand alone club can be ripped away from your club without compensation?

I for one minute don't think the competition is perfect but that's all we've got and whilst I like competing with AFL clubs ild also like to have our seconds back to allow development of players and for a smooth transition to playing for the firsts wether that be working your way up through gaining form or coming back from injury.

 

The future? What would fans like to see ? Although I got a crystal ball at the top of my head, it rarely works properly (if it did ild be a billionaire by winning on the share market) - I was flicking through Terry Keenans book from 2005 who was commenting on this very same issue nearly 2 decades ago. He was proposing that the AFL get their own competition and that a full afl reserves competition wasn't too far away. Here we are some 18 years later and not much has changed, the discussions year after year are understandably repetitive. Who knows if and when it happens could be in 2 years could be 22 years. 

I know I'm probably the minority but ild like to see my club compete in the very best competition it possibly can and if that's vs AFL 2nds clubs so be it - I just wish, hope and pray that more consideration can be given to the stand alones and that interference of our clubs by the AFL which often hinders our chances of achieving our on field goals is kept to a minimum.

aj9172 Tue, 7 Feb 2023 - 13:10

In reply to by MegaA

Good points you make MegaA, thanks for taking the time to post that.

I think for the stability of our clubs, yes it would be great to have a development league back, but from a purely Frankston standpoint it might be a debacle. Right now the club has the best relationship it has had with our local clubs in my 40 years of following them, and probably the biggest gripe I ever heard from the MPNFL clubs was "why should we let them have our best players only to watch them sit on the bench or run around in the twos". That would be a bit of a problem for us. I imagine for you guys at Port you're probably not so reliant on one local competition to provide players like we are. I imagine Willy and Werribee share our issue (WRFL), Coburg and Preston (EDFL and NFL) too. If only the competition had the stature it had 30 years ago, then maybe VFL seconds wouldn't be seen by local clubs as a pointless competition. 

In terms of this becoming an AFL reserves, we're almost there already. The remaining aligned AFL teams are swallowing the identities of their old VFA counterparts more every year. It's a matter of time before Sandy, Box Hill and Casey (they're pretty much already Melbourne) change their names and it's done. 

When we were forced to take on the NEAFL clubs my first thought was "are the AFL insane? We can't have a competition with that many teams".....and no, in the longer term they can't and they would know it. But, they can have a lovely reserves comp of 14 teams once the standalones realise they can't possibly stay competitive and either fold or drift off to local or amateur leagues. THAT'S the future the AFL wants, and it's hard to see how they won't get it the way things are headed.

MegaA Tue, 21 Feb 2023 - 19:33

" I imagine for you guys at Port you're probably not so reliant on one local competition to provide players like we are. "

Thats right, Port as you may know recruits from a variety of sources including interstate - this season for example they recruited a youngster from the TFL (was voted the most promising youngster to play in the TFL)  a couple of players from Queensland - these are off the top of my head, theirs likely to be more. The most common place that gets looked at is the Oakleigh charges which has been beneficial in finding some great players whereas others don't end up living up to expectations but i digress - yes you are correct with Port not recruiting from any one league in particular they don't have the problem of local club resentment - its been years since we recruited a local. I hear your point about local clubs not being happy with youngsters leaving to play 2nds but at the end of the day i'ld think ultimately its the players decision where they want to play, if they want to play local having a kick with their mates in a much easier league in the aspects of training, commitment and physicality or wether they want to push themselves and give the highest standard state comp a crack and possibly get seen by some bigger name clubs i would think is a decision that local clubs are not in a position to dictate. 

"..they can have a lovely reserves comp of 14 teams once the standalones realise they can't possibly stay competitive and either fold or drift off to local or amateur leagues. THAT'S the future the AFL wants, and it's hard to see how they won't get it the way things are headed."

 

I do often hear the comment that the AFL wants us all gone and admitedly i may have been somebody who at one point has said something similar. I have no doubt that our clubs are of little significance to the AFL and if they were to fold we'ld be quickly forgotten however I do believe that the AFL has acted in a manner that would indicate that their is some kind of care factor and perhaps in the past ive been mistaken in my assumption that they want us removed. A few examples of this can be seen by

- waving the licensing fees for our clubs,

- reducing the salary cap (yes on field performance suffered but it also protects clubs from reckless spending, if they wanted us gone they could have said go for your life spend what you like but it'll be done at your own peril), 

- listening to VFL clubs who said playing 6 players under 22 was too many are reducing that to 3 - this will allow our clubs to be more competitive 

- paying for all interstate travel and accommodation for our clubs

- assisting clubs in ground upgrades- I think Coburgs, Port Melbourne and Werribees ground upgrades were partially funded by the AFL

The AFL has not been without fault towards our clubs but when I (and possibly others) consider the above it does put doubt in my mind if they really do want us gone - after all if they did want us to fade away into obscurity it would be very easy for them to make us do so however some of their actions oppose this notion.  

aj9172 Wed, 1 Mar 2023 - 06:47

You make many good points MegaA......perhaps we at Frankston need to start looking further afield for our recruits. I guess at all the clubs we have to look at what we stand for. Perhaps the Dolphs are too mired in the old concept of "community football" and being representative of the lower Mornington Peninsula from the VFA days. I guess while we do have a heavy reliance on the MPNFL to produce talent, the club has recruited pretty well from the Cranbourne-Narre region and the Eastern league too in recent years. I know we've had a few lads from the Eastern Ranges to go along with the many from Dandy Stingrays. We definitely need to look further afield, because there are talented players running around in lower leagues all over the country.

The salary cap is a real issue I think, and troubling. Yes we need the cap there to enable the smaller clubs to survive, but we also need to make it large enough that our state leagues (am speaking for the SANFL and WAFL here too) are elite competitions in our states, Surely it's alarming to most clubs to see our captain and long term servant Josh Newman head to Mornington because they gave him "an offer he couldn't refuse". There are cashed up local clubs out there quite happy to steal our players. Not a good sign for the future of our clubs if we can't outbid local clubs.....and we have 22 of them to compete with down here. Be under no illusions, here on the MP we are just another fish in the pond in that regard.

Bearsman Topic starter Wed, 1 Mar 2023 - 12:23

Well said AJ.100% agree with everything you say, I have a bit of a problem with how Frankston are now 'marketing' thmselves on social media.Seems they now see themselves as a 'factory' producing  AFL players. I  would rather see them trying to attract players who want to to play finals footy and win premierships. F**k the AFL draft - if players get drafted so be it, but surely they should be seen to be building a strong team with a loyalty culture that is hell-bent on winning a premiership? This year will be a couple of steps back for the Dolphs, but hopefully they can get back on track, but from what Im hearing it's not going to be easy. Hopefully McLaughlin will piss off soon and the new man will do something about this ridculous salary cap situation. Yeah, I know, pigs can fly...

aj9172 Wed, 1 Mar 2023 - 14:51

In reply to by Bearsman

Yeah Bearsman, this issue of WHAT we are as a footy club is such a problem. I agree with you, that in the long run promoting ourselves as draft pathway is a road to ruin, on and off the field. I'm not being critical of those who have driven that line over the years (we go back to Simon Goosey as the initiator of it eh) because I know they were just looking for ways to get talent IN the door. Unfortunately it's pretty short-sighted.

I've followed and been involved in admin of sport for 40 years, and if there is anything I've learned about recruitment and membership of clubs is that it's all about the emotions that club makes people feel. Particularly, people want to identify with a club on a personal level. I remember as a kid seeing heaps of kids out on the ground after the game in Frankston jumpers with their favorite player's numbers on them. These days, if there's 20 kids in total at our games we'd be lucky. That's way beyond alarming. I'm not going to single out the transient playing list as the only reason for that (I know of at least one other major factor in the lack of families) but gee it doesn't help. My son has become a pretty keen supporter, but if you ask him who his favorite player is he will say "well it WAS (insert name)".....because players just don't stay long enough. I understand Josh leaving us, but I won't lie, I'm bloody angry. Whatever we do in the next couple of years we MUST hang on to Will Fordham, who now has to take the role of talisman and bring the young fellas along for the ride. 

For all the great work that has been done off the field to resurrect our club I'm eternally grateful to those that have done so much. But I know for a fact it will all be for nothing if we don't start getting the community involved and build a decent membership. The only way this can be done is to show the community a team that is here to play for Frankston, and that want to take Frankston to the top. Anything less won't captivate anybody for any length of time.

Bearsman Topic starter Mon, 6 Mar 2023 - 10:33

Not much to get excited about after the first practice match but still a few senior players to come into the team - Fordham Williams etc. We were relatively competitive in the first quarter but went to mush after that. Only kicking 1 goal 3 for the match shows what a struggle its going to be this year for the Dolphs to kick a score. Losing McLaughlin, Begley and co from the forward line is really going to hurt. Hopefully, there will be some improvement next week vs Essendon.

aj9172 Mon, 6 Mar 2023 - 13:13

Agreed Bearsman, it was pretty depressing......though I think the scoreline is a little deceptive since that howling wind into the forward pocket wasn't letting anyone score much for the first two games. It seems it let up a bit to allow a bit more scoring for the Port v Coburg game.

I'm trying to put it into perspective, given that apparently we had 12 players rested and 10 of them would be walk up starts. And it was against pretty much the full strength Werribee side. 

Yes we will find out a bit at The Hangar this coming weekend. Some of these kids might show something surrounded by some more experienced heads. They better, or it's gonna be a long year.