Somthing to talk about during the off season,i thought i would rate all the v.f.l grounds ,not the playing surface but conditions for the fans(cover,seats,food,social rooms,toilets,terrace etc) Bendigo=6lots of cover,big stand Box Hill=4 a bit hilly,not much cover coburg=3 stand ok but dirty,get rid of cricket club spend money will be ok Frankston=8 allways cold pies,dirty toilets but is bench mark of v.f.l Geelong=6 not for v.f.l Nth Ballarat ? only ground havnt been to,but dont like cars in ground Bullants=2 crap port=7 very good Sandy=6 good maybe asphalt some sections but keep hill grass Springvale=2 bring on cassy can only get better Bellerive=9 Tassies M.C.G Werribee=4 i hate this ground to small, slippery when wet toilet stinks bad Williamstown=6 not bad toilets a bit far away,maybe ashphalt the wings Anyone else want to have a go.
vfa Mon, 14 Nov 2005 - 09:59

Moorabbin played at Bentleigh Rec before they folded. I never went there so I cannot rate the ground. Sunshine played at Selwyn Park before moving to Skinner Reserve Sunshine. Anyway Billy the Kid the crowd for the double header was very ordinary just the same. A ground like the MCG a crowd of 13,000 seems bare with a ground as big as the G. I was aware of Dandenong playing at the Dandy Showgrounds. Ironacly Dandy West is called Dandy Demons and has a touch of Dandenong VFA as they want to take over them. They play in the old dandy colours and eventually want to play at Shepley Oval. I went to watch the Dandy Demons play Doveton Eagles there this year. Albanvale played some of their home games at selwyn Park this year in the WRFL as their home ground was getting a facelift. Never got to the ground to have a look. We can add Springvale's new ground at Casey Fields next year to the list. Also don't forget Lavington as a ground where the Murray Kangaroos played a few games there.
jb Tue, 15 Nov 2005 - 20:26
Official attendance at the '86 double header at the 'G was 6253. VFA very dissappointed, given that Jacko's debut earlier in the year for Brunswick against Sandy drew 13,000 (would have been a tight fit at the Gillon). Favourite current grounds (other than Willy) are Port and Sandy as viewing is good all around the grounds and they are real traditional VFA feel to it. Least favourite is North Ballarat - while facilities good, no atmosphere. Looks terrible on ABC as cameras face the outer. Favourite old grounds Camberwell, Northcote and Toorak Park (great 2nd Div finals venue).
STANGA Tue, 15 Nov 2005 - 21:14
I'm only going to write about grounds i've been to on game day, as that's the only true way to guage them. Box Hill - I do like it, but i understand the grief shown over it. It's because we're leafy eastern suburbians, and people don't really rate the east for some reason. Positives-: The terrace. Old fashioned, quite a height above the surface, feels like the footy should when you stand there ( except for all the weak hawthorn supporters), the hedge around the ground, now that's a rarity today. On a sunny day, half of the ground comes up a treat. It's the car park on the other side that annoys me. The lame "grandstand", knock it down or refurbish it to actually being a grandstand. Look, i'll give it a 7/5 Coburg - i absolutely love this ground, more than most, and i can't really say why, but i just feel like i'm at the footy when i'm at this ground. Since my beloved Richmond took over the joint, hasn't felt the same, but the terracing's great, down in front of the grandstand has a great atmosphere, i love georgies kiosk, 3 dimmies thanks, the dude with the dog standing under the scoreboard. Great grandstand, i really think finals, even grand finals should be a goer at this ground. 9/5 Frankston - Haven't been there since it's been fixed up, but it did have a good feel about it. Bit of a country feel. Being in the grandstand, it feels a lot better than what it looks on tv, and because the grounds so narrow, you really feel on top of the game. 7/5 North Ballarat - a little bit better when you're there than on tv, but no character. They might have the best facilities, but give me a wooden shed and some character above that cold, lifeless place. 3/5 Preston - Everyone bags the ground, i genuinely rate it as on of my favorites to travel to. Great terracing, great grassy hill, Fantastic grandtand, quite high, very central, and beautiful trees surrounding the ground, i reckon it's a beauty. Don't forget, if these grounds were full, we'd say "Great atmosphere"! 8/5 Port Melbourne - It's great. Love the tram ride out there, the grandstands, hill, burraburgers, i think everyone knows why this ground is great. Atmosphere, a sense of history. Don't need to go into detail. 9.5/10 Sandy - Another great ground. Isn't Telstra Dome boring. LOVE the wall around the ground, might be the last of its type. The Punt Rd. and Junction ones are gone. The quirkiness off the beach, the word Zebras painted on the grandstand room, has a real finals feel about it. Doesn't hold heaps, but went to a Frankston v Coburg final here in i think 2001, about 3000 there, it was wonderful. A nice bit of the world down there. 9/10 Newcomben Rd. - Bit of a sad old ground. Love how the grounds represent the area and the clubs. This was a working class club, with a working class ground. Need some shelter? Slap up a tin shed. Sad to see it go, but glad it came back this year for a last chance to get out there. But honestly, 5/10 Werribee - Don't mind it. Worlds smallest grandstand, little cover, a lot of brown soil around, but the atmosphere of the club just makes it work. 7/10 Williamstown - Not my favorite ground, but definately my favorite road trip. Just feels like a carnival down there. Love the grandstand, like port, you can feel that they've been there for 100 years.
bcarbonaro Tue, 15 Nov 2005 - 22:01
In general, I think most of the grounds are up to scratch except Newcomen Road and it's great the Scorpions are moving to a new facility which sounds like it will be awesome.
vfa Wed, 16 Nov 2005 - 16:02

Billy the Kid error- crowd was 6253 at the MCG double header and not 13,000 as stated by you. Thanks to JB for pointing the crowd out. I was at the MCG for the double header as well as being at Gillon Oval to see Jacko play for Brunswick against Sandy. Over 13,000 crammed in at the old Brunswick Ground which was sensational stuff. Unfortunately Brunswick could not win this particular game. These days they are lucky to get half that crowd for a Grand Final. A lot of old VFA supporters who barrcked for the Camberwell, Sunshine, Oakleigh, Dandenong, Prahran, Caulfield and other defunct VFA teams have sadly no interest. That's why you need some new blood into the comp. Maybe a Vermont or Noble Park would breathe some life. Sad to see a lot of good players from the VFL being lured to the SANFL and WAFL for the dollar. It also does not help players with aligned clubs as the VFL listed players do not get a regular game. Bring in the 12/10 or even 11/11 rule for the whole season. We do not want a Northern Bullants type 17/5 ratio. Not good for the comp.
footyman Wed, 16 Nov 2005 - 18:39
STANGA wrote:Werribee - Don't mind it. Worlds smallest grandstand, little cover, a lot of brown soil around, but the atmosphere of the club just makes it work. 7/10
Couldn't have said it better myself about Werribee. Good post overall STANGA, agree with what you say on the grounds.
foz Wed, 16 Nov 2005 - 23:52
I agree vfa , some new blood , particularly some of the elite teams from suburban comps could give the league a much needed lift . The afl reserves alliances do not seem to have worked !
bcarbonaro Thu, 17 Nov 2005 - 09:16
footyman wrote:[quote:698fb6450a="STANGA"] Werribee - Don't mind it. Worlds smallest grandstand, little cover, a lot of brown soil around, but the atmosphere of the club just makes it work. 7/10
Couldn't have said it better myself about Werribee. Good post overall STANGA, agree with what you say on the grounds.[/quote] Yeah, good to see no one is bagging our great Chirnside Park.
Dolphin Thu, 17 Nov 2005 - 09:42
bcarbonaro wrote:Yeah, good to see no one is bagging our great Chirnside Park.
Read my review. They need to fill in the drainage on the (toy) Stand side of the ground before we lose a boundary umpire. And keep the cars out of the ground so the hoons (reserves players) don't drop 900 cans abd become a rabble during the seniors.
NorthPort Tue, 22 Nov 2005 - 22:57
Thought I'd post this in here from another thread:
CGull wrote:[b][u]GROUND RATINGS[/u][/b] Greetings,just joined today really enjoyed all the articles especially vfa’s trip down memory lane.thought I might list my favourites and not so favourites. [b]Williamstown Cricket Ground[/b]-on a clear day is there any better place to watch footy? On a bleak day can be totally opposite.Can remember Fred Cook shooting for goal and the ball actually landed behind him,true story. The club is on the verge of signing off on plans for an$8.8 million redevelopment of Pt.Gellibrand with a huge new social club with 360 degree views which will be amazing,means that bloody embarrassing portable will go. Meeting place-Stags Head Hotel best pub in the town,great beer and food 10 minute walk from ground. [b]Port Melbourne[/b]-very atmospheric,great surface,charming old social club burra burgers but really miss the aroma from the donut van which used to park next to the entrance. Meeting place-Railway club hotel opposite light rail stop,lovely old pub breat beer and Tab. [b]Frankston-[/b]always very welcoming,excellent surface,very scenic and very entertaining if you stand on terraces next to the ferals.Has terrific social club no worries in wet weather. Meeting place-Grand Hotel,5 minute walk,good beer and food if a little rough around the edges. [b]Preston-[/b]love going to Cramer St,had some great contests over theyears although always seem to play there on awful days,ground heavy like Mornington racetrack. Disagree with previous correspondent re social club,love it in there,always go in after game and mix with Bullant faithful. Meeting place-Cramers,one minute walk,Tab,big pub with little atmosphere. [b]Box Hill-[/b]lovely big ground,much improved from the bog they used to serve up.intimate social club and old grandstand,not worried by lack of cover,always go armed with wet weather gear as you’re in the middle of rain belt. Meeting place-Blackburn Hotel,ok pub but good 20 minute walk. [b]Sandringham-[/b]lovely ground,great surface,can get as blowy as Willy,excellent social club with outdoor viewing area although now infiltrated by chardonnay sipping Melbourne toffs who couldn’t care less about the Sandy blokes Meeting place-Sandringham Hotel-10 minute walk down Beach Rd,tab,big pub but has lovely bay views. [b]Bendigo-[/b]magnificent grandstand steeped in history,surface always heavy,large social club run by Sth Bendigo F.C I think. Meeting places-many and varied,plenty of old pubs and restaurants,suggest overnight stay if possible. Some not so favourites- [b]Werribee-[/b]large with no atmosphere surrounds always boggy.On plus side terrific social club,no worries if wet. Meeting place-Racecourse hotel,2 minute walk,best steak sangers around,worth the trip alone,tab and good beer. [b]North Ballarat-[/b] should be closed in winter,fair dinkum it snowed the first time we played there,absolutely no atmosphere except for car horns.Ground falls away to one side and wind blows straight across ground shocking to watch and near impossible to play any sort of cohesive footy.On plus side fantastic social club. Meeting place-as above. [b]Coburg[/b]-one of the few places I dislike going to.Only positive is Meeting place-public bar of the Summerworld Hotel with that charismatic old barman who seems to have been there for years.Great place for a beer and a bet,in fact sometimes easy to stay all day especially if getting flogged.Apologies to any Coburg [not Richmond] fan who may read this. [b]Springy and Dandy not applicable thank goodness.[/b]R.I.P Loved going to Yarraville,Northcote,Waverley,Oakleigh to mention a few,but my all time fave would have to be Toorak Park,any visit there meant the day in the Prahrantonians room with your own barrel,toilet,lots of racing people and an unbelievable atmosphere.Essential to have a flexi day booked for the Monday. Anyway get out of your armchairs and comfort zones,away from the dreadful AFL andget to a vfl venue and even better buy a bloody membership.See you there,cnt wait for 2006.