Forum topic

4 posts / 0 new
Last post
Spiny Norman
Last seen: 5 min 33 sec ago
Joined: 31/03/2025 - 12:53
Squad for VFL Team of the Year selection
Body: 

The squad of 48 from which the VFL Team of the Year will be selected has been announced here:

https://www.afl.com.au/news/1606968/2026-smithys-vfl-team-of-the-year-squad

From the article:

"The full list of club representation is: Box Hill Hawks (four), Brisbane Lions (two), Carlton (one), Casey Demons (one), Coburg (six, including Mitch Podhajski), Collingwood (two, including Harrison Coe and Mitch Podhajski), Essendon (two), Footscray (two), Frankston (six, including Harrison Coe), Geelong Cats (four), Gold Coast Suns (one), GWS Giants (two), Port Melbourne (two), Richmond (one), Southport Sharks (two), Sydney Swans (two), Tasmania (three), Werribee (four) and Williamstown (three). North Melbourne, Sandringham and St Kilda do not have a representative named."

Box Hill: Stu Horner, Henry Hustwaite, Finn Maginness, Brodie McLaughlin

Brisbane: Darragh Joyce, Will McLachlan

Carlton: Lachie Fogarty

Casey: Riley Bonner

Coburg: Jack Bytel, Ingo Dammersmith, Cooper Keogh, Jaidyn Stephenson, Donovan Toohey

Collingwood/Coburg: Mitch Podhajski

Collingwood/Frankston: Harrison Coe

Essendon: Tyler Sellers, Elijah Tsatas

Footscray: Jack Billings, Cooper Craig-Peters

Frankston: Corey Ellison, Darby Hipwell, Tyson Milne, Trent Mynott, Jackson Voss

Geelong: Nathan Kreuger, Mitch Knevitt, Jesse Mellor, George Stevens

Gold Coast: Ben Jepson

GWS: Harvey Hooper, Jack Ough

Port Melbourne: Kaine Baldwin, Ben Hobbs

Richmond: Mutaz El Nour

Southport: Jacob Dawson, Zac Foot

Sydney: Joel Hamling, Mitch Mellis

Tasmania: Hugh Dixon, Jed Hagan, Jye Menzie

Werribee: Ajang Kuol Mun, Louis Pinnuck, Jack Riding, Brady Wright

Williamstown: Jake Greiser, Luke Parks, Jack Toner

Bit surprised Brayden Crossley didn't make the squad. I did think AJ Kuol Mun had a narrow win over him when Werribee played Southport, and perhaps the games he missed cost him the squad spot. Two in the squad seems a bit low for Port Melbourne given the sixth-placed finish, but to some extent we did have different players excelling at different points in the season. From Werribee I had expected to see Dom Brew and Charlie Lazzaro in the squad, but there is always a lot of competition for the midfield spots. Sandringham's Nathan Philactides perhaps a bit unlucky. In any case the selectors should certainly be able to pick a strong team out of this squad.

NorthPort's picture
NorthPort
Last seen: 16 hours 45 min ago
Joined: 03/11/2003 - 00:00

Bloody hard task to pick a VFA/VFL team of the year now with so many sides in the comp. Who are the ruckman selected in that side? (Ignorance on my part).

 


* It's time to restore the VFA name.

Spiny Norman
Last seen: 5 min 33 sec ago
Joined: 31/03/2025 - 12:53

Harrison Coe, Cooper Keogh, and AJ Kuol Mun. Don't think there are others - those are the names I recognize as ruckmen and also the 3 with hitouts listed as a stat in the article. I've been tipping Kuol Mun for the ruck position in the team since I think he did beat Crossley in their head to head, but looking at the stats for Werribee's game against Coburg, it looks like Keogh won that ruck battle. I don't think I actually watched that game, though. 

Yes, the number of sides in the comp does make it tough to pick a team. Corey Ellison surely gets in as the Frosty Miller medallist, and then some players will be stiff to miss out no matter who they select for the team. Tried to pick just a starting midfield (admittedly not having watched widely enough to have the most informed opinion), and I'm not sure how they'll narrow it down.

Spiny Norman
Last seen: 5 min 33 sec ago
Joined: 31/03/2025 - 12:53

The final team and all award winners now announced here: https://www.afl.com.au/news/1612713/mynott-stevens-share-liston-eaves-breaks-through-for-lambert-pearce

Has it ever happened before that the top 2 Liston vote getters were both ineligible through suspension? 

I remain unconvinced that Hobbs' suspension was deserved. This is at least not only Port Melbourne bias since my first reaction to a suspension at this point is usually to wonder if it's an overreaction to a football act. [Edit: Well, from what Hobbs himself said about it, it was a fair suspension. Good seasons by him, Dawson, Mynott and Stevens.] At any rate, while I have many thoughts about the quality of the VFL umpiring, none of them complimentary, we do now know the umpires aren't unfairly biased against suspended players in the voting - I'd thought there was no chance Hobbs would finish with the most votes because he wouldn't poll as many as he deserved after the suspension.