Official discussion thread!

I was hoping Werribee would make it through for the good of the competition, as they still appear to be a club in their own right, whereas Box Hill really aren't their own club anymore with the jumper change, song change and name change etc.

Still it might bring a bigger crowd along or it could work against the VFL, with general supporters less likely to attend a 'reserves' Grand Final.

From what I saw of todays game, it's difficult to see the Hawks really challenging Geelong. I wonder what impact Friday nights game between the two clubs will have on selection.

Wally from Wil… Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 15:05

In reply to by billythekid

billythekid wrote:

zebraman wrote:

digs wrote:billythekid wrote:

Billy, I'm not in love with the yanks either, but to say you didn't shed a tear when 2000 people lost their lives is way over the top.

Agree Digs... Billy, you're entitled to your opinion, but what you said was very very ordinary....still can't believe I read that comment...poor form

Think what you like but having lived and visited countries ruined by the yanks like Angola,Iraq,most South American countries etc for their own gain so I dont back away from any comment Ive made

Btw I dindt say I support terrorism in any form just that you sow what you reap and the USA is no different to many other countries that get a hammering because of their actions.

Israel is one that comes to mind Pakistan is another both allies of the US!

Don't forget what they did in Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos, Chile, Nicaragua & god only knows what other countries they have destroyed for their own strategic & economic benefit .....

digs Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 18:48

In reply to by Wally from Wil…

Wally from Williamstown wrote:

billythekid wrote:

zebraman wrote:digs wrote:billythekid wrote:

Billy, I'm not in love with the yanks either, but to say you didn't shed a tear when 2000 people lost their lives is way over the top.

Agree Digs... Billy, you're entitled to your opinion, but what you said was very very ordinary....still can't believe I read that comment...poor form

Think what you like but having lived and visited countries ruined by the yanks like Angola,Iraq,most South American countries etc for their own gain so I dont back away from any comment Ive made

Btw I dindt say I support terrorism in any form just that you sow what you reap and the USA is no different to many other countries that get a hammering because of their actions.

Israel is one that comes to mind Pakistan is another both allies of the US!

Don't forget what they did in Vietnam, Cambodia, Laos, Chile, Nicaragua & god only knows what other countries they have destroyed for their own strategic & economic benefit .....

Billy, Wally, Zebraman & Clarry. Time to put that one to bed I think.

digs Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 18:56

In reply to by BrekkyDJ

BrekkyDJ wrote:

digs wrote:

Borough1874 wrote:If it wasn't for north Ballarat having a 2's side I can fairly confidently say Isaac smith would not have won a flag today.

Borough ...I can confidently say that that is bullshit.

Actually, I think it's a very good point.

I wonder if Sammy Dwyer would have ever made AFL if we didn't have a 2nds.

If your good enough you can get picked up from anywhere.
The bulk of the Roosters that have gone on to play AFL footy never played reserves footy.
Lockett, Malthouse, Perovic, Burns, Lewis, Clarke all played senior BFL football at 16 years of age.

Borough1874 Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 18:56

Sam Dwyer was playing 2's for port in 2006-07 even part of 08. If it wasn't for the 2's he would more than likely be back in the bush.

Isaac is no different. The task would have been a more even impossible task for him to. Go from playing at Redan to Ballarat ones's in one great big stride.

vfa Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 19:17

Isaac Smith has played in a premiership team with the Sewell Brothers. Myles with the roosters and of course the Hawthorn Sewell yesterday. What a great kick by Isaac Smith with that long goal to give Hawthorn momentum late in the GF yesterday.

digs Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 19:24

In reply to by vfa

vfa wrote:

Isaac Smith has played in a premiership team with the Sewell Brothers. Myles with the roosters and of course the Hawthorn Sewell yesterday. What a great kick by Isaac Smith with that long goal to give Hawthorn momentum late in the GF yesterday.

Had to be the BEST kick of the day !!!

digs Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 20:04

In reply to by vfa

vfa wrote:

billythekid wrote:

vfa wrote:One of the most pox afl grand finals I have seen. I have gone to every vfl/afl GF as well as vfa/vfl grand final since Kevin Bartlett had hair as well as well as the days of Max Papley. The third quarter was reasonable but to have a GF with a half time score line of 5 goals to one with trash footy ??

Why didn't Hawthorn wear Box Hill mustangs jumpers today ?

On a serious note great to see Isaac Smith playing in a afl premiership team.

From Redan to North Ballarat seconds and a flag for the roosters seniors in no time.

I was hoping the other vfl player in Michael Barlow would do well and win a Norm Smith.

Speaking of Norm Smith medalist, remember when Brian Lake who was known as Brian Harris back then playing his first vfl game for Werribee and lining up on Plugger Lockett at Port Melbourne. The borough was trailing by heaps at half time but stormed home to win.

vfa I think you had better get used to the fact that the stronger AFL seconds teams could and will make the GF from here on in fact they could even dominate the finals system.

The only way this lopsided comp can gain credibilty is to split in two and have a play off GF betwwen the two groups.

Billy I was talking about yesterdays AFL GF as well as ex VFL Isaac Smith, Michael Barlow as well as Brian Lake/Harris playing his first game.

You might be right with a lopsided comp. Then again I would not count Port Melbourne and Williamstown as well as the improving Frankston as bottom and struggling teams.

The AFL standalone teams need injury free and the right mix of players. Also helps if there AFL team is still in afl finals. I would not say that the afl standalone teams will dominate. Williamstown will be in at least the top six teams next year. Port depends on who they lose and who they gain for next year. Frankston will improve further and can make finals next year.

Was Tony Lockett the BEST full forward ever to play with Port ???

digs Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 20:04

In reply to by vfa

vfa wrote:

billythekid wrote:

vfa wrote:One of the most pox afl grand finals I have seen. I have gone to every vfl/afl GF as well as vfa/vfl grand final since Kevin Bartlett had hair as well as well as the days of Max Papley. The third quarter was reasonable but to have a GF with a half time score line of 5 goals to one with trash footy ??

Why didn't Hawthorn wear Box Hill mustangs jumpers today ?

On a serious note great to see Isaac Smith playing in a afl premiership team.

From Redan to North Ballarat seconds and a flag for the roosters seniors in no time.

I was hoping the other vfl player in Michael Barlow would do well and win a Norm Smith.

Speaking of Norm Smith medalist, remember when Brian Lake who was known as Brian Harris back then playing his first vfl game for Werribee and lining up on Plugger Lockett at Port Melbourne. The borough was trailing by heaps at half time but stormed home to win.

vfa I think you had better get used to the fact that the stronger AFL seconds teams could and will make the GF from here on in fact they could even dominate the finals system.

The only way this lopsided comp can gain credibilty is to split in two and have a play off GF betwwen the two groups.

Billy I was talking about yesterdays AFL GF as well as ex VFL Isaac Smith, Michael Barlow as well as Brian Lake/Harris playing his first game.

You might be right with a lopsided comp. Then again I would not count Port Melbourne and Williamstown as well as the improving Frankston as bottom and struggling teams.

The AFL standalone teams need injury free and the right mix of players. Also helps if there AFL team is still in afl finals. I would not say that the afl standalone teams will dominate. Williamstown will be in at least the top six teams next year. Port depends on who they lose and who they gain for next year. Frankston will improve further and can make finals next year.

Was Tony Lockett the BEST full forward ever to play with Port ???

vfa Sun, 29 Sep 2013 - 22:24

In reply to by digs

digs wrote:

vfa wrote:

Isaac Smith has played in a premiership team with the Sewell Brothers. Myles with the roosters and of course the Hawthorn Sewell yesterday. What a great kick by Isaac Smith with that long goal to give Hawthorn momentum late in the GF yesterday.

Had to be the BEST kick of the day !!!

Easily the best kick of the day.
Isaac was certainly rapt with his long goal.

billythekid Mon, 30 Sep 2013 - 06:22

When are the VFL going to finalise the teams that will make up the comp next year?