Port to drop the 12/10 rule?

A rumour going around on Bigfooty's North board, is that the Borough have decided to withdraw the rule, in the best interests of team selection. If it is genuinely going to be picked on form, then I reckon a few players from both lists will be close to being dropped for the next game against the Roosters.
Dolphin Fri, 29 Apr 2005 - 16:29
I would think it would be foolhardy to drop the rule, but at the same time stating where players are to comer from (12/10) is also a bit dangerous. If you make a stand, as Port, did by stating that will will play to a rule, then there is a significant problem when you drop it; it reaks of panic, and I don't expect that they are at that stage. In simple terms, players should simply be picked on form. Form alone will mean that the split between the 12/10 or whatever will find its own natural level. By doing this, Port has the ability to be a club unto itself, as it should be.
Dolphin Fri, 29 Apr 2005 - 16:45
Dolphin wrote:............a stand, as Port, did by stating that ..............
Hate it when I get my commas in the wrong spot!!
C_LEWIS Fri, 29 Apr 2005 - 16:58
I must say that I was horrified when I first heard about the rule and I was dead set against it. I don't have that much of a problem with it but I really believe that this should be just one of the initiatives that the VFL needs to introduce to restore the competition back to its former glory. Firstly, let's do away with the fictions and rename it the VFA. Secondly, insist that even though most clubs must have alliances with AFL teams, all clubs should have their own independent identity i.e. colours, nickname, club song etc. Thirdly, go out and market the competition. Get it in front of the media and be a little adventurous with venues, times and other forms of promotion. Otherwise, we're going to constantly be banging our heads against the wall and hearing the usual from AFL commentators who constantly refer to it as the "twos" which is where it's all heading (if it's not there already).
C_LEWIS Fri, 29 Apr 2005 - 16:59
I must say that I was horrified when I first heard about the rule and I was dead set against it. I don't have that much of a problem with it but I really believe that this should be just one of the initiatives that the VFL needs to introduce to restore the competition back to its former glory. Firstly, let's do away with the fictions and rename it the VFA. Secondly, insist that even though most clubs must have alliances with AFL teams, all clubs should have their own independent identity i.e. colours, nickname, club song etc. Thirdly, go out and market the competition. Get it in front of the media and be a little adventurous with venues, times and other forms of promotion. Otherwise, we're going to constantly be banging our heads against the wall and hearing the usual from AFL commentators who constantly refer to it as the "twos" which is where it's all heading (if it's not there already).
boroughboy Fri, 29 Apr 2005 - 18:24

if port drop the 12/10 rule it will surely smack of a shipwithout a rudder. saultry introduced it so lets see how brave he is now that the heat is on. he opened a can of warms so lets see if he will eat them
NorthPort Topic starter Sat, 30 Apr 2005 - 02:36
I think the concept of the 12/10 rule is good, but maybe its a case of being good on paper, but not practical, either for balance, or just having a balanced side. If they do decide to drop the rule, then at least they have addressed it early in the season, rather than stubbornly play on with it if isnt working.
footyman Sat, 30 Apr 2005 - 10:11
Port were never certain about it from the outset. At the start of the year, Port had the rule "for now" and they would see how it worked for a few weeks.
cobrascorer Sun, 1 May 2005 - 19:50
Bendigo had about 16 AFL players in their last two matches, and not many Bendigo district local players. If it, and other teams packing with AFL players reach the finals, their stability will be upset by having the team unbalanced. This was talked about on ABC tv game 30/4/2005 by Scorpions coach and Phil Cleary.