Ons...followed Port Melbourne's fortunes with interest...is it a Port problem or an AFL problem???
Sydney Swans didn't work..
Kangaroos didn't work...
We've heard the Port Melbourne side of the argument espoused bt Peter Saultry...
I sometimes get the impression that perhaps the problems lay with Port Melbourne...
I coul;d be wrong and stand to be corrected...
The OFFICIAL view is that the kangaroos were the trying to run the Borough....haven't heard any rumblings from either Tasmania or Ballarat as yet...so I ponder if maybe the problem actuallty lay within the Port Melbourne????
Forums
Zebraman, as far as I know.. the Sydney aligment fell through because of the mounting costs of flying 20+ people (players and staff) down every week.. Spoke to Paul Roos (I think he was an assistant coach in 2002) after a game at the Port rooms, and he said he was happy with how it was working from a selection perspective.
With the Kangaroos aligment, it was always pretty rocky I think, it seemed to come to a head with Port dropping Shane Harvey to the twos. There was rumours about the Roos threatening to pull players etc.. make of that what you will.
I'd say the Kangaroos realise they have no alternative but to make these current alignments work, if they are as happy as they are portrayed (such as the picture of Laidley sitting with the North Ballarat president).
Ons...
As with many things...I wonder if all genuine supporters get is the "OFFICIAL" version of what is happening rather than the ACTUAL version
I am increasingly cynical of "official" versions of what is actually happening
this cynicism applies not only to VFL football, but to events that are actually happening in the world right now..
and here I am at 0300 watching Charlton V Blackburn Rovers...the Jack Daniels is alive and well..
Go Zebras later on today
I think the important factor with all AFL clubs regarding alignments is their players develop.
An idea may be that some AFL clubs align with two teams even though it is more difficult geographically it could be the way to go. Therefore instead of having 12-16 AFL players playing you may have a maximum of 8.
I am not sure why Saade Ghazi would reply to Dean Laidley's comments, why the alignment failed is not the concern, it is where Port go from here.
I know it is only early in the season but watching yesterday's game after 1/4 time it was like watching a senior team against an u/19 team.
The most important point in all this is that the old VFA clubs survive and maintain their identity.
With all due respect to the player concerned why should an AFL listed player not be dropped to the reserves if he is not performing?
I'm sorry to have to single out one individual but I saw Harvey play a couple of times for Port and he wasn't much cop on the days I saw him.
Surely, if there's a kid busting a gut and playing well in the VFL reserves it would kill the competition completely if he couldn't gain a promotion for his efforts because some AFL player had some sort of immunity from being dropped.