Port Melb Signings?

Does anyone know if port Melbourne have signed any decent players? I don't mean your becker's and Plemings (Pleb Pleming will be lucky to get a game), I mean senior players with afl experience, players that will get them into the finals.
zebra Thu, 8 Dec 2005 - 19:50
:D Without trying to help Port MELB. TOOOOO much I have seen Bonnadio play,reserves 2 games, last season 2005, first game he kicked 10 goals and looked awesome, next game finals ,he only kicked a couple of goals but that wasn't his fault entirely. He is raw and stands tall and takes a good mark and could develope into a very good forward . Port would want to keep this fella for themselves and not let him go as he has a good future in the VFL. Maybe those that saw more of him know his true form and prospects as a future goalkicker. go zebs.
rico Thu, 8 Dec 2005 - 20:34
Definately a top liner in the making zebra but I'd be very surprised if he wasn't rookied. Blokes his size who can run and take a contested mark dont grow on trees. If by chance he does slip through , Port will have a seriously good key forward in 06. Also , just on Port. I'm sure they'll be working pretty hard on at least one or two name players but surely their main aim for 06 would be to build a solid base of 'good ordinary footballers' , the types you build a club around. Ummm , you know , blokes like Nick Becker and Sam Pleming !! Judging from conversations with port people at the end of the season , they're quite committed to taking the longer , but more reliable, path up the mountain. Not that I wish em any luck of course !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :wink:
zebra Fri, 9 Dec 2005 - 19:54
:D Zebraman you make your own luck,as you know following the MIGHTY ZEBRAS over many years, you must take the not so good with the best. And I am sure the VFL competition this coming year 2006 will be as keen as ever with many new and old players giving their best for their clubs jumper. go zebs. :wink:
footyman Mon, 12 Dec 2005 - 18:47
The Leader had this story in it this week about Port signings: PERTH ruckman Warren Carlyle and Coburg Tigers midfielder Nick Raines are the latest players to sign at Port Melbourne. Carlyle, who was second in Perth's best and fairest this year, is known in the VFL for his stint at Coburg from 2002-04. Raines is the son of former champion centreman, Geoff, and was a Queensland Under 18 representative in 2000 and 2001 and a Brisbane rookie in 2002. He joined Coburg last year to play alongside his brother Andrew, who is listed with Richmond. The bonus from Port's point of view is that its new stand-alone status means it will not have to pay Coburg a transfer fee.
localboy Topic starter Thu, 29 Dec 2005 - 09:19
Port Melbourne ins: Matthew Smith (Adelaide Crows) Brayden Shaw (Collingwood) Luke Peel (Port Power)
NorthPort Thu, 29 Dec 2005 - 20:25
Thanks for the news localboy, what do people know of Matt Smith and Luke Peel? Smith is a tall (190+ cm) who has been at the Crows for several years, but has barely played an AFL game.
bcarbonaro Fri, 30 Dec 2005 - 00:43
Yeah, both of these boys did well at time at SANFL level. Can try and fide out some more information.
deaddack Fri, 30 Dec 2005 - 07:50
Being a follower of the SANFL can confirm that Matt Smith is a pretty solid player maybe could have made it at the next level if given an opportunity. Luke Peel really struggled - basically played reserves football for the couple of years in SA. He is young however and may improve.